What Hi Fi Sound and Vision Fri, 20 Dec 2013, 1:00pm

Sony PlayStation 4

Tested at £349
80100
4

Next-gen gaming is a glorious reality but you’ll have to make do without some last-gen features

Write your own review

For

  • Simple set-up and interface
  • Games look and sound great
  • Good selection of TV, film and music apps
  • Decent AV performance

Against

  • No 3D Blu-ray, CD or DLNA support
  • Not as good as a dedicated disc player

You’ve done well if you’ve managed to miss the launch of the Sony PlayStation 4. First announced – albeit without so much as a hint of the console itself – back in February, all sorts of hype and hyperbole followed throughout the year.

Now the PS4 is finally a reality and in shops in time for Christmas – and in time to do battle for next-gen console supremacy with Microsoft’s Xbox One.

More than a games console?

Much of the talk around these new consoles for much of the year has concerned their role as all-singing, all-dancing entertainment hubs, ready to take centre stage in your living room and your AV system.

However, in the months before launch, Sony took a step back from this, suggesting the PS4 is in fact “for the players” – a games console first and, indeed, second.

Sony PlayStation 4

Microsoft has kept on the home entertainment tack, making much of the Xbox One’s TV integration and the addition of a Blu-ray player. However, as our Xbox One review reveals, the console is far from the finished article in that respect.

MORE: Watch our Sony PS4 unboxing video

Sony, of course, already made this play for the home entertainment market with the PlayStation 3, propelling itself in to AV hearts and minds by being one of the very first Blu-ray players, while also offering a host of other disc and network playback options.

So, does the PS4 carry on where the PS3 left off? Or is it games over features to the detriment of the wider home entertainment functionality? Let’s find out…

Build and design

Sony PlayStation 4

The PlayStation 4 design looks more like the PS2 than the PS3 – “a PS2 on the wonk” is how we described it in our unboxing video – but it’s certainly more compact and generally easier on the eye than the black block that is the Xbox One.

The angular edges, touch-sensitive front buttons and glowing blue power strip make for a suitably next-gen appearance.

It can stand flat or upright, though you’re advised to use the official stand if you want to place it vertically. It’s an optional extra, despite being pictured on the box.

MORE: Read our Sony PS4 hands-on preview

What is inside the box is one of the new DualShock 4 wireless controllers (but no DualShock charging cradle), a mono headset (a cheap-looking earbud), an HDMI cable, USB cable and a power cable.

Unlike the Xbox One, the transformer is integrated inside the PS4, so there’s no need to worry about finding a home for a hefty external power block.

Specs

Sony PlayStation 4

The PS4’s connections come in the form of an HDMI and a digital optical output, two USB 3.0 inputs and an auxiliary connection for the new PlayStation Camera (an optional accessory for around £60).

There’s an ethernet connection too, though the PS4 also has built-in wi-fi. There are no analogue connections, however – an omission that raised some eyebrows at launch.

Talking of which, much of the muttering in the What Hi-Fi? offices has centred on the slot-loading DVD/Blu-ray drive, which gives us the first sign that the PS4 really isn’t looking to please all of the people all of the time in the way that the PS3 did.

It will happily play PS4 games, Blu-ray discs and DVDs, but the drive won’t play 3D Blu-rays or CDs. Strange but true.

Sony PlayStation 4

The reaction to these missing features appeared to take Sony by surprise, and Shuhei Yoshida, President of Sony’s Worldwide Studios for Sony Computer Entertainment, has since announced that an update to allow these features may well roll out. We shall see.

There’s also no DLNA streaming – another feature present on the PS3 – nor is there support for streaming Bluetooth audio or generally playing your digital music collection.

So while the original PlayStation, the PS2 and the PS3 all jumped aboard the disc of choice at the time (CD, DVD and Blu-ray respectively), it seems Sony doesn’t see the 3D Blu-ray, or streaming your own personal audio, as worth including at launch.

Apps and features

Sony PlayStation 4

Why? Well, there are two obvious reasons: the first is the gaming focus we mentioned earlier, and the second is that Sony would rather you used the PS4’s apps for streaming music and video, mainly Sony Music (monthly subscription) and Video Unlimited (pay-as-you-go).

There are other apps for music and video available from the PlayStation Store too, such as BBC iPlayer, LoveFilm and Netflix. It’s just your own media that’s harder to get on to the console.

The PS4 comes with 500GB storage – and you can upgrade this by replacing the internal hard disk – but this is mainly for saving games.

It’s a sign of the times that even a console that puts gaming front and centre still offers all sorts of extra entertainment. The PlayStation Store sells apps, movies, TV shows and access to Music Unlimited, as well as games, and there’s an internet browser and Facebook integration too.

Sony PlayStation 4

This carries over in to the PlayStation network, pulling through your real name, pictures and friends, should you so desire.

Navigation is essentially through two rows of icons. The top one provides access to what Sony presumably sees as the most crucial aspects of the experience.

It’s something of a mish-mash, combining standard shortcuts to settings and your profile with icons for your PlayStation gaming ‘trophies’, messages, notifications and a link to the PlayStation Store.

Drop down a level and your games and apps appear in order of most recently opened. Move along the row and additional information for each appears below in a series of tiles.

These can take a second to load, whereas the interface itself is nice and nippy. It’s a ‘Dynamic Menu’, no less, and it looks smart. Jumping between open apps – iPlayer to gaming, say – will take 10 seconds or so, which while understandable can’t help but feel like a delay compared with the multi-tasking experience on smartphones and tablets.

Control

While Microsoft makes a big play of the Kinect system, which comes bundled with the Xbox One, your first port of call for controlling the PS4 will be the standard controller, the new DualShock 4. It’s a big improvement.

It feels more comfortable; the grips are a little bigger and seem more ergonomic, fitting nicely in our hands. The triggers seem more accurate and can do more too, with a greater range of control.

At the top of the controller is a new touch-pad. At launch this doesn’t seem to offer too much.

There’s also a light panel on the top edge of the pad. This changes colour to identify different characters, and is also used to track player movement.

MORE: PlayStation 4 vs Xbox One

The new PS4 controller also has a standard headphone jack. The bundled mono headset takes the form of a single earbud, so don’t get too excited by that, but the good news is you can connect any pair of headphones to hear PS4 audio, immediately overriding the PS4’s soundtrack.

And sound quality is decent. We also tried a gaming headset, the Creative SoundBlaster Evo ZX, which makes the most of the surround-sound gaming soundtracks. (And it’s worth remembering that gaming headphones are a great way to make the most of the immersive soundtracks if you haven’t got external speakers, a cinema system or a soundbar.)

Sony PlayStation 4

Another control option is the PlayStation App, which lets you connect your smartphone (Android or iOS) and enjoy some second-screen action on certain games, while also allowing you to enter text on the PS4 using your mobile.

Sure enough, this proves better than the PS4 on-screen keyboard at entering addresses in the web browser. The internet browser itself is fairly easy to use using the dual sticks to move the cursor, although Flash videos won’t play and jumping around links on a page is still a little clumsy.

The PS Vita can connect for handheld gaming of your PS4 titles, too.

PlayStation Camera

Sony PlayStation 4

The PlayStation Camera, which is used for voice and gesture controls, isn’t included in the box but rather an optional accessory (yours for around £60).

It’s a lot smaller than the new Kinect, which Microsoft aims to make more integral to the Xbox experience – hence it’s bundled with the console – and in reality a lot less impressive.

An app, The Playroom, feels rather shoe-horned in to the PS4 experience as an effort to show off what the Camera can do and essentially it’s simply some neat but quickly fairly dull augmented reality.

There are limited voice commands, too, but no gesture control – and it feels similar to smart TVs, fairly effective but unlikely to replace the hard control for most people.

Still, it’s easy to be jaded about technology that is potentially incredibly clever and powerful. Again, this is a ‘watch this space’ feature.

DVD and Blu-ray

So, it won’t play 3D Blu-rays or CDs. But how does it perform with what it can play? More than adequately – but not a patch on a dedicated player. It gives away sharpness, dynamic colour and overall detail.

Motion isn’t handled quite as smoothly either. Our PS4 could also be a little noisy in operation, too.

But in isolation the picture is perfectly watchable. There’s little sign of noise, colours are presented faithfully and the level of insight is adequate. DVD pictures are less impressive.

Killzone Shadow Fall

The drop in quality is obvious, but the difference between DVDs on the PS4 and a dedicated machine are more obvious. Again, there’s nothing too off-putting, but lines are softer and there’s a drop in detail.

Sonically, it sounds a little less substantial, too.

It can output high-def Dolby Digital and DTS 5.1 soundtracks via HDMI or digital optical, but you don’t get the same power and weight to heavy-hitting effects when watching bombastic blockbusters like Pacific Rim, nor are voices as expressive – even if dialogue is perfectly clear.

Again, it’s a trade-off for the extra features but if this will be your main disc-spinner, it’s a good budget player and no more.

Sony’s Music Unlimited service works pretty nicely. There’s an extensive library and a fast, neat interface.

The bit-rate is now thankfully up to 320kbps, to match the likes of Rdio and Spotify, and it sounds fine as streaming music goes. Background audio from Sony Music Unlimited is a neat touch (you need to pay your £10/month for any of this of course) and, unlike the Xbox One, you can adjust your music volume level and game audio level separately.

We found having both a bit distracting and messy but clearly for other PS4 tasks having music playing is neat.

Games

Assassin's Creed Black Flag

Of course, it’s in the gaming arena where the PlayStation 4 comes in to its own. There’s no backwards compatibility with PS3 discs, but you will be able to buy digital copies of your existing games.

PS4 launch titles include Battlefield 4, Knack, Assassin’s Creed IV: Black Flag and Call of Duty: Ghosts. And they all look great – even though we still expect to wait a bit of time for developers to get the best out of the hardware.

Killzone: Shadow Fall is probably our favourite title at the moment, thanks to its neat use of the new controller, great surround-sound effects and detailed, expansive landscapes to enjoy – all running in glorious 1080p/60fps.

Call of Duty: Ghosts

Much was made of the new CoD game arriving in 1080p on the PS4 and 720p on the Xbox One, and while the differences might be a tad over-stated, having played both consoles, the PS4 would be our pick for gaming purists.

There’s no 4K gaming for now, though. That’s still on our wishlist.

The online gaming services on offer will no doubt help many people choose which console to buy. Sony’s come courtesy of PlayStation Plus, a subscription service that is very reminiscent of Microsoft’s equivalent, Xbox Live.

It’s worth noting that the service doesn’t need you to be a paying subscriber to access apps such as Netflix and LoveFilm, as you do on the Xbox.

Sony PlayStation 4

Verdict

Sony has been clever with the PS4. Gaming is the theatre in which it wants to win the next-gen console battle, and on this evidence we think it might just have the first victory in the bag.

It’s undoubtedly the PS4’s strongest string, which may be no great surprise, but with all the talk of the wider home entertainment capabilities of such devices, is no longer a given.

Neat integration of catch-up TV and streaming music and movie apps is good too (and indeed practically a necessity), but there’s no denying that some of the holes in the wider spec sheet are big and disappointing.

The PS4 has already sold by the bucket load and will no doubt continue to do so – and for arguably the best all-round gaming experience around, we don’t disagree with those stumping up the cash.

But if, like us, you want it do much more, you may find yourself a mite disappointed – at least for now.

 

Follow whathifi.com on Twitter

Join whathifi.com on Facebook

Find us on Google+

 

Latest offers