29 posts / 0 new
Last post
pwiles1968's picture
Offline
Last seen: 3 months 4 weeks ago
Joined: 22/03/2009 - 10:55
Posts: 700
Sonos ZP90 or Apple TV

I am yet to dip my toe in to the world of WiFi and mass media storage but I am thinking about it predominantly for Music Playback I still have a CD Player and piles of CD's in the front room, I think I know know techanically what I need but wnated to know a bit more about the interface of both the above units.

I like things like the genius mixes/playlists on iPod/Tunes and think I may like the album searches selection via the  Plasma that AppleTV will offer, the sonos offers the ability to control it via a PC and I assume this would mean I could control it with my netbook while I sit in front of it, Can I do this with the Apple?? How good are the sonos random or genius style modes.

  Anyone used both of these and can shed some light on the user experience, I would be using both via a NAS with lossless media feeding the digitally to my AV amp.

manicm's picture
Offline
Last seen: 23 hours 36 min ago
Joined: 01/05/2008 - 12:57
Posts: 2699
Re: Sonos ZP90 or Apple TV

If you have a NAS then the quick answer is Sonos .

The_Lhc's picture
Offline
Last seen: 22 hours 37 min ago
Joined: 16/10/2008 - 13:23
Posts: 12897
Re: Sonos ZP90 or Apple TV
pwiles1968:

I am yet to dip my toe in to the world of WiFi and mass media storage but I am thinking about it predominantly for Music Playback I still have a CD Player and piles of CD's in the front room, I think I know know techanically what I need but wnated to know a bit more about the interface of both the above units.

I like things like the genius mixes/playlists on iPod/Tunes and think I may like the album searches selection via the  Plasma that AppleTV will offer, the sonos offers the ability to control it via a PC and I assume this would mean I could control it with my netbook while I sit in front of it,



Well you can do that, using the Desktop Controller, but it's not the ideal solution, ideally you'd be using one of the handheld controllers, whether it's the CR200 of the iPhone/Touch/Pad controller.

How good are the sonos random or genius style modes.



Sonos doesn't have a genius mode (I'm not even sure what that is to be honest), as to the random mode, I'm not sure what to say, how random is random, it plays tracks in a random order, there's not much more to be said really.

  Anyone used both of these and can shed some light on the user experience, I would be using both via a NAS with lossless media feeding the digitally to my AV amp.



I've never used AppleTV but that's exactly how I use my Sonos ZP90 and it's great, easy as cake.

SnowyJohn's picture
Offline
Last seen: 6 months 5 days ago
Joined: 17/11/2009 - 12:06
Posts: 236
Re: Sonos ZP90 or Apple TV

Apple TV versus Sonos... Sonos is obviously audio only, but it does a great job and can be easily expanded to multi-room functionality. If you are at all considering the future of digital video then Apple TV is the more versatile.

 

HOWEVER... I would consider a Mac Mini. Firstly, it's a fan-less, rather energy efficient computer! Coupled with a NAS, it can be a beast of a system. It can act as a music server, media player, home theatre system - especially if you'd like to plug it into a plasma.

 

I've just picked up a 2GHz Mac Mini (under 1 year old) for £370. Although it's the pricer option, it ticks a lot more boxes and with an iphone/ipod or ipad and the 'Remote' app (free) is an itunes controller downloadable from the app store.... if you ever want to upgrade to multi room there are a number of possibilities, but Airtunes (via Airport Express through itunes) is a pretty neat package. Especially if you already have one of the i-devices mentioned...

 

Also: It should be worth mentioning, I've tried the Squeezebox option as a cheaper alternative to Sonos as I have a NAS which could run Squeezecenter. When dealing with ALAC (Apple lossless) files, the NAS has to transcode each track. Unfortunately the 500MHz processor on the NAS isn't fast enough to do this without stuttering playback. I figure I should sell the squeezebox now, but am annoyed that I paid £5 for 'ipeng' (SB controller app) which is considerably more sluggish than 'remote'.

The_Lhc's picture
Offline
Last seen: 22 hours 37 min ago
Joined: 16/10/2008 - 13:23
Posts: 12897
Re: Sonos ZP90 or Apple TV
SnowyJohn: It should be worth mentioning, I've tried the Squeezebox option as a cheaper alternative to Sonos as I have a NAS which could run Squeezecenter. When dealing with ALAC (Apple lossless) files, the NAS has to transcode each track. Unfortunately the 500MHz processor on the NAS isn't fast enough to do this without stuttering playback. I figure I should sell the squeezebox now, but am annoyed that I paid £5 for 'ipeng' (SB controller app) which is considerably more sluggish than 'remote'.



Does SB transcode FLAC? If not you could convert the ALAC files to that and try it.

SnowyJohn's picture
Offline
Last seen: 6 months 5 days ago
Joined: 17/11/2009 - 12:06
Posts: 236
Re: Sonos ZP90 or Apple TV

I believe it supports FLAC natively so it wouldn't need to transcode, but to be honest, I haven't given it much thought. I have over 80GB's of ALAC, all nicely documented on iTunes, so I really haven't given much thought to the idea of creating a whole seperate FLAC folder.

It also occurred to me that playing FLAC files through my SB Boom would be pointless. That said, I would like to play lossless audio through my main 'rig', so could do with spending some time considering my options.. Currently I just plug my iphone into a dock and use an app to play music from the NAS if I want music it a secondary room. << this isn't a major concern at the moment, but I always like to consider future expansion options.

pwiles1968's picture
Offline
Last seen: 3 months 4 weeks ago
Joined: 22/03/2009 - 10:55
Posts: 700
Re: Sonos ZP90 or Apple TV
the_lhc:    Well you can do that, using the Desktop Controller, but it's not the ideal solution, ideally you'd be using one of the handheld controllers, whether it's the CR200 of the iPhone/Touch/Pad controller.


 I agree and as airing toward an iTouch but could use that on top of either system so not a deciding factor for me, also that may come later and thoght I may get a basic a syatem up and running first.


Sonos doesn't have a genius mode (I'm not even sure what that is to be honest),  


 Genius takes a track and creates an intelligent playlist of similar music from your library, a feature I really like on iTunes iPod.

SnowyJohn's picture
Offline
Last seen: 6 months 5 days ago
Joined: 17/11/2009 - 12:06
Posts: 236
Re: Sonos ZP90 or Apple TV
pwiles1968:

 Genius takes a track and creates an intelligent playlist of similar music from your library, a feature I really like on iTunes iPod.

I agree, genius is a great feature. People will have differing opinions but I find that providing you have a large enough library of the genre/tempo of the track selected to base a genius playlist on, it works brilliantly.

However, AFAIK, you won't find this sort of feature on other devices... just plain ole' useless random. << Good if your entire library is of one genre and you happen to be in the mood for it.

FYI, the 'Remote' app can be used to control genius playlisting... It's a solid system.

The_Lhc's picture
Offline
Last seen: 22 hours 37 min ago
Joined: 16/10/2008 - 13:23
Posts: 12897
Re: Sonos ZP90 or Apple TV
SnowyJohn:
pwiles1968:

 Genius takes a track and creates an intelligent playlist of similar music from your library, a feature I really like on iTunes iPod.

I agree, genius is a great feature. People will have differing opinions but I find that providing you have a large enough library of the genre/tempo of the track selected to base a genius playlist on, it works brilliantly.



Interesting, this is one of the most requested features over on the Sonos forums I noticed today, so you're not alone in that.

However, AFAIK, you won't find this sort of feature on other devices... just plain ole' useless random. << Good if your entire library is of one genre and you happen to be in the mood for it.



Not sure I'd agree with that, I only ever listen to my collection on random, precisely because I want the genres to be mixed up, it makes things far more interesting.

SnowyJohn's picture
Offline
Last seen: 6 months 5 days ago
Joined: 17/11/2009 - 12:06
Posts: 236
Re: Sonos ZP90 or Apple TV
the_lhc:Not sure I'd agree with that, I only ever listen to my collection on random, precisely because I want the genres to be mixed up, it makes things far more interesting.

I could of course been more general and say some people may be perfectly happy with plain old random... Personally, I like different genres at different stages of the day and "random" doesn't suffice - I would be forever skipping tracks. If you haven't already, give genius a go. Genius Mixes are a newish feature on itunes, basically preset playlists based on your music, for example, Brit / Indie mix, Dance mix, Classical etc etc... Again, a nice way of quickly listening to a specific type of music. 

The_Lhc's picture
Offline
Last seen: 22 hours 37 min ago
Joined: 16/10/2008 - 13:23
Posts: 12897
Re: Sonos ZP90 or Apple TV

I don't use itunes.

SnowyJohn's picture
Offline
Last seen: 6 months 5 days ago
Joined: 17/11/2009 - 12:06
Posts: 236
Re: Sonos ZP90 or Apple TV

... I figured that.

The_Lhc's picture
Offline
Last seen: 22 hours 37 min ago
Joined: 16/10/2008 - 13:23
Posts: 12897
Re: Sonos ZP90 or Apple TV

How would you suggest I try the genius mode then?

brendonw's picture
Offline
Last seen: 8 months 6 days ago
Joined: 24/05/2010 - 11:58
Posts: 222
Re: Sonos ZP90 or Apple TV

No point as you are obviously not one.............

 

Stick out tongue 

Dan Turner's picture
Offline
Last seen: 4 months 1 week ago
Joined: 09/07/2007 - 22:50
Posts: 1012
Re: Sonos ZP90 or Apple TV

I vote for Sonos if you're happy for it to be audio only.  Went from streaming itunes to Airport Express to a Sonos and I couldn't be happier with the switch.  Last FM does something similar to Genius playlists, albeit, streaming over the web, and not restricted to your music collection, which I guess has some good and some bad aspects to it in comparison with iTunes Genius playlists.

 

pwiles1968's picture
Offline
Last seen: 3 months 4 weeks ago
Joined: 22/03/2009 - 10:55
Posts: 700
Re: Sonos ZP90 or Apple TV
Dan Turner:

I vote for Sonos if you're happy for it to be audio only.  Went from streaming itunes to Airport Express to a Sonos and I couldn't be happier with the switch.  Last FM does something similar to Genius playlists, albeit, streaming over the web, and not restricted to your music collection, which I guess has some good and some bad aspects to it in comparison with iTunes Genius playlists.

 

 Yes I do like Last FM especially finding new artists and will no doubt use it but not for 'Sit Down' listening sessions when I will be using lossless media. I must say I was allways looking at the Sonos as my first option just wanted to know what the alternatives were.

 Can you import your iTunes Playlists in to the Sonos player if so I can make my own playlists off the back of genius mixes.

Also can you use your PC as an audio source in the sonos system, i.e. could I have a sonos in the kitchen linked to one in front room and also be listening to the same music in the back room? 

Pages

Log in or register to post comments