Have your say & ask the experts!

SACD vs DVD Audio

26 replies [Last post]
shado's picture
Offline
Joined: 22 Aug 2008
Posts: 531
__________________

AV - Samsung 40D8000, CA Azure751BD, Yamaha YSP2200

Hifi - Cyrus CD6SE, 8XPd, 6 Power, KEF iQ50, ZP90

Wifi - Cocktail Audio X10 1TB/NAS, Sonos S5/ZP90/120

Wharfedale Diamonds 9.0, B&W Zeppelin, Kef Picoforte
Soundscience Frankenspiel USB Speakers

Al ears's picture
Offline
Joined: 23 Nov 2008
Posts: 2434
RE: SACD vs DVD Audio

............... and the answer to the non-existant question is SACD by a knockout.

(due, if anything to the amount of available source material)  excellent!

__________________

Origin Live Aurora Gold+Illustrious Mk2 arm+Zyx R100-02/Stello CDT200+Stello DA220 dac/Tom Evans Groove Anniversary phono amp/Tom Evans Vibe preamp/Linear A power amp/Acoustic Zen Adagios/Chord cables/Oppo 105EU.

HDNumpty's picture
Offline
Joined: 18 Jan 2008
Posts: 263
RE: SACD vs DVD Audio

Who cares?

__________________

Music: Stream Magic 6, Apple Airport Express, CA 840a, B&W CM1

Movies: Pana 37" plasma, Denon DBP-1161ud, Humax YouView HDR, Sony DA-2400ES, MS surrounds, REL Sub

Mobile: iPhone 5 64GB, Audio Technica ES7, Sony XBA3, Monster iBeats

unfocused's picture
Offline
Joined: 21 Jun 2009
Posts: 97
RE: SACD vs DVD Audio

HDNumpty wrote:

Who cares?

lots of people, including me

Joined: 27 Jun 2008
Posts: 10864
RE: SACD vs DVD Audio

A well mixed 5.1 album can be very enjoyable, and quite an eye opener with regards to how much more information (sometimes instruments!) there is on the disc. I'm picking up a few here and there to try out, although I'm avoiding paying a fortune for them.

__________________

David @Frank Harvey Hi-Fi, Coventry

Official Record Store Day participants!

jetjohnson's picture
Offline
Joined: 11 Aug 2007
Posts: 165
RE: SACD vs DVD Audio

For my money DVD-A has the edge sound quality wise ....although if it's about what's available SACD wins hands down. And as for who cares ...many audiophiles do! - there a quite a number of surround discs that sound fantastic ...check out a few of Steely Dan and Donald Fagen's recent albums to hear how good 5.1 audio can be.

Let's just hope that multi-channel Blu Ray audio discs can fill the gap left by DVD-A.

 

__________________

Oracle Delphi 1 / Zeta /Goldring 2200. Onkyo Tr 875. Marantz CD 85 SE.Sony CDX 355 300 Disc CD Multi-Player

Lake Audio 1015 Ft Speakers and Lake Audio Ctr. Wharfdale Diamond III Rears. Ruark Vita 100 Sub Woofer. Pioneer PX 50d Plasma. Denon 1940 DVD. Panasonic DMR ex 777 HD/DVD-R.  Pioneer 989 avi DVD Player.  Sony BDP185 Blu Ray player, Sky HD Box

 

Al ears's picture
Offline
Joined: 23 Nov 2008
Posts: 2434
RE: SACD vs DVD Audio

Here's us all wittering  on and we still don't know what shado's original post might have read.

My opinion is that DVD-A died a death because it was simply inferior to the established SACD format pure and simple.

Is have quite a few SACD's both stereo and multitracked and still buy them now and again.

I'm not about to get into BluRay audio just yet as I feel its not going to take off.

Come back shado and repost your question. Smile

__________________

Origin Live Aurora Gold+Illustrious Mk2 arm+Zyx R100-02/Stello CDT200+Stello DA220 dac/Tom Evans Groove Anniversary phono amp/Tom Evans Vibe preamp/Linear A power amp/Acoustic Zen Adagios/Chord cables/Oppo 105EU.

BigH's picture
Offline
Joined: 29 Dec 2012
Posts: 3300
RE: SACD vs DVD Audio

The problem with SACDs is the cost in the UK they are often 4x or more expensive than the standard cds. It is also debatable how long the format will last, if I were you I would go for a blu-ray DVD player which will play both cds, sacds and dvds..

shado's picture
Offline
Joined: 22 Aug 2008
Posts: 531
RE: SACD vs DVD Audio

sorry orig post read was soundbar versus hifi in context to DVD Audio and SACD

Linda Ronstadt with Nelson Riddle orchestra via CA 751BD and Cyrus 8XPd/KEFs (DVD-A)192k/24bit is wow, CD 48K/16bit via CD6SE is great and via Sonos 256 is still acceptable track - Someone to watch over me.

Rosemary Clooney White Christmas SACD hybrid sounds good through both 751BD/Soundbar & Cyrus CD/Amp/Kef  slightly better via Cyrus. Same with SACD of original Jeff Wayne War of the Worlds, richard burton vocal more natural via Hifi route.

However Celtic Spectacular SACD from Telarc was more enthusiastic via soundbar as the blue light on YSP 2200 lit up most likely through trickery of HD surround format but nevertheless v impressive

__________________

AV - Samsung 40D8000, CA Azure751BD, Yamaha YSP2200

Hifi - Cyrus CD6SE, 8XPd, 6 Power, KEF iQ50, ZP90

Wifi - Cocktail Audio X10 1TB/NAS, Sonos S5/ZP90/120

Wharfedale Diamonds 9.0, B&W Zeppelin, Kef Picoforte
Soundscience Frankenspiel USB Speakers

fr0g's picture
Offline
Joined: 7 Jan 2008
Posts: 2877
RE: SACD vs DVD Audio

One problem with SACD is it isn't easily backed up.

A problem with both is selection. My tastes are mainly obscure. No hope of finding a disc in these formats.

The only advantage of either is surround. Sound quality is equal assuming the same master.

Both are (as good as )dead anyway.

__________________

“Out beyond ideas of wrong and  right, there is a field.

I'll meet you there."

 

 

Al ears's picture
Offline
Joined: 23 Nov 2008
Posts: 2434
RE: SACD vs DVD Audio

'as good as dead anyway' ??

That's what they said about vinyl! Smile

__________________

Origin Live Aurora Gold+Illustrious Mk2 arm+Zyx R100-02/Stello CDT200+Stello DA220 dac/Tom Evans Groove Anniversary phono amp/Tom Evans Vibe preamp/Linear A power amp/Acoustic Zen Adagios/Chord cables/Oppo 105EU.

dariushifi's picture
Offline
Joined: 9 Apr 2011
Posts: 68
RE: SACD vs DVD Audio

You can burn your own DVD audio CDs.

It can be filled with hours of hi-res music. In some cases it may be very handy.

__________________

SONY Bravia 32 EX723, Denon DBP2012UD, Naim UnitiQute, B&W685, Nac A5, Chord Active HDMI 1.4, Chord Crimson Plus

fr0g's picture
Offline
Joined: 7 Jan 2008
Posts: 2877
RE: SACD vs DVD Audio

Alears wrote:

'as good as dead anyway' ??

That's what they said about vinyl! Smile

Vinyl at least has a point...ie...

Touchy-feelies who want big versions of artwork and want to get as close as possible to the potential quality of 128K MP3 by spending thousands on cartridges and tonearms...etc and DJ's who like to scratch something real. They're the musical equivalent of Instagram...cool and retro, or naff and second rate depending on your viewpoint. 

Smile

 

But SACD or DVD-A are dead ducks. Nothing to see here.Please move on.

 

__________________

“Out beyond ideas of wrong and  right, there is a field.

I'll meet you there."

 

 

lonely boy's picture
Offline
Joined: 19 Apr 2008
Posts: 291
RE: SACD vs DVD Audio

fr0g wrote:

Please move on.

 

Wish you would bud.

Al ears's picture
Offline
Joined: 23 Nov 2008
Posts: 2434
RE: SACD vs DVD Audio

+1 to that.

__________________

Origin Live Aurora Gold+Illustrious Mk2 arm+Zyx R100-02/Stello CDT200+Stello DA220 dac/Tom Evans Groove Anniversary phono amp/Tom Evans Vibe preamp/Linear A power amp/Acoustic Zen Adagios/Chord cables/Oppo 105EU.

fr0g's picture
Offline
Joined: 7 Jan 2008
Posts: 2877
RE: SACD vs DVD Audio

Fair enough, I deserved that.

But the lack of ability to back-up seriously put me off SACD. It's a shame that there is no multi-channel download option (as far as I am aware of).

 

 

__________________

“Out beyond ideas of wrong and  right, there is a field.

I'll meet you there."