Amazon Prime Video vs Netflix – which is better?

Amazon Prime Video vs Netflix – which is better?

Watching films from the comfort of your own sofa no longer requires shopping for Blu-ray discs and setting aside a huge amount of shelf space to accommodate your growing collection.

There has been a similar change in watching TV – the days when your evening’s viewing revolved around Radio Times listings and programme recording are long gone.

The arrival of video streaming services has seen to that, spearheading a ‘next generation’ of TV and film viewing that looks set to stay.

For the past few years, having thousands of hours of content available to stream 24/7 to our telly at home or on the smartphone in our pocket has changed our viewing habits, making marathon film trilogies and binge-watching TV boxsets the new going out.

It doesn’t have to come at a price either, with YouTube and UK catch-up services such as BBC iPlayer and ITV Player serving up hour after hour of free streaming. What a world we live in, eh?

But none of the other services has the content diversity or versatility of the two giants of video streaming, Amazon Prime Video and Netflix. Theirs is an intense battle that mirrors the rivalry between Spotify and Apple Music in music streaming.

Both offer thousands of movies and TV shows, old and new, for as little as £6 per month. There probably aren’t enough hours in the day to warrant two subscriptions, so which service should get your vote?

Subscriptions

Amazon Prime Video vs Netflix – which is better?

For the first month, why not try both? Amazon and Netflix each offer 30-day free trials, so it goes without saying that you should reap the benefits of having twice as much content as you could ever sit through. Just because you can - and because they offer different content.

But when the time is up, so is the two services’ subscription homogeneity. Amazon offers two cancel-anytime subscription tiers: ‘Prime Video’ for £5.99 per month, which is the standard video streaming service, and a more Amazon-embracing £7.99 per month (or £79 per year upfront) ‘Prime’ membership.

This option builds on Prime Video by bundling ad-free streaming of Prime Music, unlimited photo storage in Amazon Cloud Drive, one-day shipping on select Amazon-stocked products and early access to Amazon’s ‘Lightning’ deals.

Both are inclusive of Amazon’s 4K and HDR content, and allow two screens to stream from the same account, with each video limited to one device at a time.

Netflix has a more tiered approach and, unless you’re happy settling for the standard-definition streams of the digital Dark Ages, is going to set you back more.

Up from the basic £5.99 monthly subscription, which allows SD playback to only one screen at a time, is the £7.99 tier that grants you access to high-definition streams to two screens simultaneously.

To take advantage of the 4K and HDR content Netflix has to offer, you have to sign up to the £9.99 per month premium tier, which also takes the screen count to four – a good-value family-size package, for sure.

For couples and singletons though, Amazon is the more affordable option – but when it comes to watching new 4K HDR material, Netflix now has the upper hand.

Catalogue

Amazon Prime Video vs Netflix – which is better?

Perhaps surprisingly, there’s not much crossover between the two catalogues, so paying out for both wouldn’t be as pointless as it initially seems.

It's difficult to nail down the exact number of titles for each service - figures are constantly changing as series and movies are added and removed - but it's estimated that Amazon trumps Netflix by almost double.

Size isn’t everything of course, and many will no doubt veer towards one based on commitments to certain shows that are exclusive to each of the services. Do you care more about Mr. Robot and The Grand Tour (Amazon), or House of Cards and Stranger Things (Netflix)?

Both groom their catalogues on a regular basis, vary their offerings from country to country, and pluck movies from the post-Blu-ray-release window – so don’t go expecting films that have just hit the shelves or the latest series of TV shows before the next one has started.

That said, Amazon definitely puts a greater priority on adding popular films when it can, which is why at the time of writing you'll find relatively recent hits such as The Post, Logan Lucky and I, Tonya.

Netflix is far from without third-party content, with the likes of Valerian and the City of a Thousand Planets and The Hateful Eight on board, but it's clearly more focused on its Original content.

Amazon Prime Video vs Netflix – which is better?

Today, 'Originals' (TV shows and movies produced by Netflix and Amazon’s own studios) sit at the forefront of the services’ campaigns.

Netflix has more (and perhaps more popular) programming in its repertoire, led by acclaimed dramas Better Call Saul, Orange Is The New Black, Master of None and Marvel’s Daredevil, plus smash hit documentaries such as Making a Murderer and Evil Genius.

Amazon has certainly stepped up its game, with the likes of Bosch, Mozart in the Jungle, Hand of God and The Man in the High Castle, not to mention The Grand Tour, fronted by popular petrol-heads Clarkson, Hammond and May.

It's been taking a crowdsourcing-like ‘have your say’ approach to new content, too, releasing numerous pilot episodes that viewers can vote on to determine which are turned into full-length series.

But, despite its best efforts, Netflix has always managed to stay one step ahead of its closest rival and has crept even further ahead over recent months, particularly when it comes to movies: Amazon seems determined to give most of the small number of movies it makes a run at the cinema that delays streaming availability, whereas Netflix puts everything it makes (which is quite a lot more) straight onto its own service.

Amazon Prime Video vs Netflix – which is better?

‘Originals’ is where both services’ 4K and HDR offerings begin. At the moment they’re the only material on Amazon to get the 4K treatment, with a handful of those also in HDR - right up to HDR10+ or Dolby Vision if you've got a TV capable of playing one of those more advanced formats.

Netflix similarly bigs up its original content by wrapping it in 4K and HDR (including Dolby Vision but not HDR+), starting with the first series of House of Cards and also incorporating Stranger Things, Lost in Space, Godless, Altered Carbon, Daredevil and its other Marvel character-based live action dramas, including Jessica Jones and Luke Cage.

Netflix gets one over on Amazon by throwing in a fair few 4K HDR films, such as Bright and Annihilation, although Amazon Video does offer some to rent or buy on a pay-as-you-go basis on top of your subscription.

MORE: HDR TV – What is it? How can you get it?

Amazon Prime Video vs Netflix – which is better?

Platform support

Streaming isn’t the exclusive domain of the dedicated couch potato either.

Both services are supported on a wide number of platforms, including PCs, laptops, Android and iOS smartphones, as well as TVs, Blu-ray players and games consoles, and are therefore as readily available on-the-fly as Facebook and Twitter.

Netflix has the edge here. It’s everywhere, on everything. While Amazon is now across almost all smart TV offerings, there’s no ‘almost’ about it for Netflix, which is as much of a household app on Sony, Samsung, LG and Philips televisions as BBC iPlayer and YouTube.

It also plays ball with Windows phones and Chromecast, which is more than we can say for Amazon. Instead, Amazon is much more concerned with native compatibility on the Fire phone, tablet and TV stick.

Amazon was the first to allow its subscribers to download titles and watch them offline but, predictably, Netflix has followed suit.

MORE: Google Chromecast Ultra review

Amazon Prime Video vs Netflix – which is better?

Usability

Having previously done a lot of work to simplify its user interface, Amazon Prime Video has recently become something of a nightmare to use if you're after 4K content. It doesn't come up in search results, is generally rather hidden when browsing, and is literally impossible to find in some cases.

Netflix is significantly better in this regard - there is just one entry for each show or movie, and it will automatically play in the best quality it's available in that your TV can handle. It's extremely slick.

The general approach is similar, with home screens dominated by seemingly endless lists of categories, from ‘Continue Watching’ and ‘Recently Added’ to ‘Independent Movies’ and ‘Award-winning Movies’, but Netflix is decidedly smoother and slicker in operation and does a better job of recommending new stuff that you'll like.

Usability is an area that Amazon seriously needs to improve.

MORE: Netflix nears 100 million subscribers after record quarter

Amazon Prime Video vs Netflix – which is better?Amazon Prime Video vs Netflix – which is better?Amazon Prime Video vs Netflix – which is better?Amazon Prime Video vs Netflix – which is better?

Amazon Prime Video vs Netflix – which is better?

Performance

You are unlikely to choose one service over the other based solely on performance.

On both, a good many shows and films are available in 5.1-channel surround sound and, with regards to picture, the effort each service has put towards streaming quality over the past few years has paid off – HD material looks impressively bright, clean and sharp on our LG OLED65C8PLA TV, Apple Macbook and Apple iPhone XS Max.

On the TV, it’s not a million miles from the standard you’d expect from playing a Blu-ray disc.

Through both Amazon and Netflix, lines are crisp, colours deep and motion handled as though stability has never been a streaming problem.

Unlike fast food or Bluetooth playback, the convenience of video-streaming services requires hardly any sacrifices in quality, and anyone just out of a three-year hibernation wouldn’t believe the progress that’s been made, let alone how juicy Ultra HD looks (once they’d looked up what that was).

Again, the equivalent disc format makes the most of the higher resolution, looking a touch crisper and sharper. But is the higher resolution justifiable for streaming? Absolutely. And to that end, Amazon and Netflix are equally compelling options.

Verdict

A couple of years ago, this fight would have been over by round two, with Netflix lifting the belt over Amazon’s crumpled figure.

But to its credit, Amazon has risen to challenge its rival’s long-term supremacy, pruning its service to be more competitive in terms of both pricing and catalogue.

Its user-experience still needs a lot of work, though. That 4K content is so hard to find (literally impossible in some cases) is ridiculous, and judder and clutter make Amazon Prime feel rather last-gen next to the sleek and shiny Netflix.

True, Amazon Video is arguably the most affordable way to watch 4K and HDR content and, for heavy users of Amazon’s shopping and music streaming, it’s an attractive option as part of its complete Prime package.

Netflix, on the other hand, has the global reach, is omnipresent and effortless to use. And while it's not the cheapest option, it majors in quality (both in terms of content and performance) and has a catalogue that's growing at an impressive rate. When you add all this up, we'd willingly pay extra for the better service.

*Overall winner: Netflix*