Samsung Gear Icon X (2018) review

Top-end coarseness stops these talented performers getting a wholehearted recommendation. Tested at £200

TODO alt text

Our Verdict

Samsung’s Gear Icon Xs rival the Sony WF-1000X not only because of their lengthy feature list, but because they’re talented performers to boot

For

  • Finely balanced
  • Rhythmically and dynamically adept
  • 3.4GB of storage
  • Long battery life
  • Great features for runners

Against

  • Coarseness in upper midrange and treble

It’s almost three years since last we reviewed a pair of Samsung headphones, and it’s fair to say the company’s Level-In and Level-On models weren’t received particularly well in our test rooms.

But there’s little value in being coy when you've probably already seen the star rating at the top of this review, so we should impress early on just how pleased we are with the performance of these Gear Icon X true wireless in-ears.

It also confirms 2017 has been a much healthier year for Samsung’s audio products.

Build and comfort

Irrespective of sound quality, you can usually rely on Samsung in terms of the build quality of its products and the number of features they pack in.

And while we’ve come to expect high standards from the Korean firm, we are also impressed by how well these Gear Icon Xs are designed. Aesthetically, they have an unassuming elegance we always covet in a pair of earphones.

In terms of features, we can’t help but admire their extended battery life – though Samsung’s claimed seven hours is reduced if you’re streaming from your phone, or if you’re using all of the Gear Icon X’s on-board features and marvellously consistent, fuss-free connectivity.

MORE: Best headphone deals: in-ear, over-ear, wireless and more

The series of taps and presses used to control functions such as playback, track skipping and volume level is intuitive, while the built-in Running Coaching feature – which logs your time, distance and burned calories in conjunction with Samsung’s S Health app – meshes the Gear Icon X further into your routine than any competitor.

Our favourite feature, though, is the 3.4GB internal memory - you can store up to 1,000 tracks in case your phone runs out of power (or if you want to leave it at home).

In Samsung’s world, true wireless means untethering even from the invisible leash of Bluetooth’s limited range.

But even so intelligently designed a product does not warrant our recommendation on that basis alone. For us to fully get behind the Gear Icon X, sonic performance has to be special too.

MORE: Best in-ear headphones 2017

Sound

And it is a musical performance. However, we should start by explaining the reason why the Icon Xs aren’t getting five stars: there are some rough edges.

While the balance of the frequency range is among the finest we’ve heard in a pair of true wireless in-ears, there is coarseness through the midrange and treble - especially at higher volumes - that tends to rankle after a prolonged period of listening.

It is by no means migraine-inducing, but it is noticeable from the off and impossible to ignore.

MORE: How to avoid buying fake headphones

However, in just about every other area the Gear Icon Xs’ ability is absolutely commendable.

Playing Kraftwerk’s The Man-Machine, for example, they dig out synth textures like a Time Team excavation, expressing the precise rhythmic patterns with a fine sense of timing and dynamics.

So neutral a balance, combined with an impressive amount of space, gives us access to each musical element.

MORE: Best wireless Bluetooth headphones 2017

And there’s a generous amount of bass weight to support it all, with care also having been taken to keep the low-end delivery agile and lean.

All told, Sony’s WF-1000Xs (our inaugural true-wireless Award-winners this year) are a step up, adding some extra punch, clarity and an even stricter sense of timing.

Though in absolute terms they’re the same price, their spec sheets are so different it’s difficult to make a direct comparison across the board.

MORE: Sony WF-1000X review

Verdict

So if Samsung has piqued your interest with all the tech crammed into its Gear Icon X in-ears, we’d heartily recommend you seek a pair out for an audition.

What a difference three years can make.

See all our Samsung reviews

Specifications

View All

General Information

Manufacturer Website Addresshttp://www.samsung.com/uk/
Brand NameSamsung
Product TypeEarset
ManufacturerSamsung
Product LineGalaxy Icon X
Manufacturer Part NumberSM-R140NZKABTU
Product NameGalaxy Icon X (2018)
Product ModelSM-R140

Technical Information

Sound ModeStereo
Connectivity TechnologyWireless
Wireless TechnologyBluetooth

Miscellaneous

Package Contents
  • Galaxy Icon X (2018)
  • Charging Case
  • Earbuds
  • Eartips (S, M, L)
  • Quick Start Guide
  • USB Connector(USB Type-B)
  • USB Connector(USB Type-C)
  • USB Cable
  • Wingtips (S, M, L)

Earpiece

Earpiece DesignEarbud
Earpiece TypeBinaural

Physical Characteristics

Form FactorIn-ear
Width18.9 mm
Depth22.8 mm
Weight Approximate8 g
Height21.8 mm
ColourBlack
Dimensions21.8 mm (H): 18.9 mm (W): 22.8 mm (D)

Warranty

Limited Warranty6 Month