Skip to main content

Musical Fidelity X-Ray v8/X-DAC v8 review

Musical, Ergonomic issues aside, this is an excellent player for the money, and it’s a must-hear product Tested at £1800.00

Our Verdict

Musical, Ergonomic issues aside, this is an excellent player for the money, and it’s a must-hear product

For

  • Lovely, full-bodied and articulate presentation
  • upgrade potential

Against

  • Poor display on player
  • few quibbles regarding build

What Hi-Fi? Verdict

Musical, Ergonomic issues aside, this is an excellent player for the money, and it’s a must-hear product

Pros

  • + Lovely, full-bodied and articulate presentation
  • + upgrade potential

Cons

  • - Poor display on player
  • - few quibbles regarding build

There once was a time when a CD player was a CD player; ie, it was a square box that played silver discs. Then, as manufacturers upped the quality threshold to previously unimaginable levels, we saw a proliferation of two-box designs; largely in the form of a CD transport for spinning the disc, and a digital-to-analogue converter for converting the signal to a form an amp can process.

The reasoning was to fully isolate the delicate electronics from the vibrations of the transport, and these design were largely successful in upping the sound quality threshold.

Further down the line, another design has appeared whereby the DAC and the transport remain in one box, while the power supply is isolated in another. This is mooted to have an even greater effect on playback, and if this Musical Fidelity pairing is anything to go by, it works a treat.

The X-Ray v8 is the integrated player, it includes a trans-port and DAC. However, to make it work you need to add either an outboard power supply (from £300), the matching integrated amplifier, or the powered upgrade X-DAC v8 tested here.

Before we wax lyrical about the sound quality (and, yes, we are going to), we'd better get the oddities and annoyances out. First, the CD player's display is only readable from straight on, which is annoying; second, the remote is badly laid out, which is also annoying; and third, there are minor alignment issues on the DAC's casework - again, annoy-ing.

An optical input would be good, too, though the USB port is pretty useful. Overall, we'd expect better for £1800.

Majors with a natural presentation
Nevertheless, such flaws are forgivable as soon as you hear this Musical Fidelity pairing in action. The products combine to deliver a cohesive, rich sound that makes most recordings inviting and enjoyable.

Its solid, articulate midrange gives anything from acoustic instruments to vocals an all-too-rare lifelike quality, so any type of music - from Mahler to Katie Melua - sounds incredibly appealing.

Move on to something harder hitting, like Grinderman, and though its best rivals deliver more bite and low-end punch, they also don't get close to matching the Musical Fidelity's inviting sound.

Overall, this X-Ray pairing easily earns a five-star rating. Worryingly for its rivals, it could be much better still.

What Hi-Fi?

What Hi-Fi?, founded in 1976, is the world's leading independent guide to buying and owning hi-fi and home entertainment products. Our comprehensive tests help you buy the very best for your money, with our advice sections giving you step-by-step information on how to get even more from your music and movies. Everything is tested by our dedicated team of in-house reviewers in our custom-built test rooms in London and Bath. Our coveted five-star rating and Awards are recognised all over the world as the ultimate seal of approval, so you can buy with absolute confidence.


Read more about how we test