Skip to main content

Spotify HiFi is missing something – but will it matter?

Spotify HiFi
(Image credit: Spotify / Apple)

We’re excited for the launch of Spotify HiFi. In case you missed the news, Spotify announced it would be launching a new, superior-quality audio option later this year, allowing Spotify Premium subscribers to upgrade their sound quality. 

While many details are yet to be confirmed, such as when exactly Spotify HiFi will launch, we do know some key information on exactly what is being promised, including some detail on the sound quality. As part of the company’s Stream On launch event, Spotify revealed the new service would give subscribers the chance to listen to “music in lossless audio format, with CD quality”. 

Currently, the best option within Spotify’s streaming quality settings is 'Very High', which delivers audio tracks with a bitrate of 320kbps. By comparison, a CD contains a 1411kbps bitrate. So, 'CD-quality' of around 1411kps should be a solid step up for Spotify users who are currently only enjoying 320kbps. A higher bitrate means more information, which should translate to better sound (that’s the simplified version). This is why we’re excited. 

Spotify remains comfortably the most popular streaming service, and something of a poster child – and lightning rod – for everything related to digital music. This makes it even more of a big deal that the company is, albeit belatedly, prioritising better audio quality and promoting that very idea – that you can hear your music in better quality and hopefully enjoy it more as a result – to a wider audience. But that it is doing it so 'belatedly' brings us to our problem.

Spotify is late to the party. Amazon Music HD, Deezer, Tidal and Qobuz all already offer lossless, CD-quality music – and have done for some time. But more crucially in our minds is the fact they (bar Deezer) also offer hi-res audio streaming – better-quality audio than, going from Spotify's CD-quality-focused announcement, is set to be offered by Spotify HiFi. Amazon Music HD might well end up being cheaper than Spotify HiFi, too.

Hi-res audio means tracks in even higher bitrates than CD quality. Want the numbers? Well, while CD is 16-bit/44.1kHz, these hi-res audio streams offer 24-bit up to 96kHz and sometimes even 192kHz – that's 9216kbps. That’s a lot more information, which can translate to better audio quality. So, for those of us concerned with hearing our favourite music at its best, Spotify HiFi won’t even bring the service up to the standard of many of its rivals – and that’s something of a shame.

But does the likely lack of hi-res audio on Spotify HiFi really matter? We have to be realistic, and while we certainly believe there is value in hi-res audio, it’s unlikely to matter to most people. 

For starters, it’s far from a given that most people would hear the benefits – if you’re listening on AirPods, on a budget audio system or even just in a less-than-optimum environment, it’s unlikely that the extra detail delivered by hi-res audio will have you jumping out of your seat; you do need a decent system to make the most of it. And while using the best possible ingredients in your sonic cake regardless still sounds like good advice to us, for many people hi-res audio may be akin to an expensive spice that you ultimately struggle to taste in the final product.

There’s also the not-insignificant fact that to actually hear hi-res tracks you need products that can play it. To play hi-res audio on an iPhone, for example, you need an external DAC. That undoubtedly knocks out a huge swathe of Spotify’s audience in an instant. Other manufacturers, such as Sonos, had also decided that CD-quality is high enough and eschewed hi-res support, though Sonos did slightly shift its stance with the launch of the Sonos S2 platform

Spotify

(Image credit: Spotify)

Even for those of us who want the best possible sound and have a good hi-fi system to make the most of it, there’s a whole other argument of whether a hi-res audio file always does deliver a better sound compared to 'just' lossless audio. A well-mastered, carefully produced lossless file or a hi-res audio file that’s come from not-so-great source material? That debate rages on. 

We also know that existing streaming services can already sound different playing the same track at the same apparent bitrate, so bitrate alone is far from the only factor affecting audio quality.

With all that in mind, for Spotify and the lion’s share of Spotify’s audience – and perhaps even, some committed audiophiles – it seems unlikely that the lack of hi-res audio will be an issue. So let's focus on the positive news: the world’s biggest streaming music service is upping their audio game and putting superior sound quality on the agenda. We certainly can’t wait to try Spotify HiFi and see how it compares to its rivals, in both their lossless and hi-res forms... 

MORE: 

Which is the best music streaming service?

Which is better? Spotify vs Tidal

33 Spotify tips, tricks and features

Everything we know about Spotify HiFi

Joe Cox

Joe is Content Director for Specialist Tech at Future and was previously the Global Editor-in-Chief of What Hi-Fi?. He has worked on What Hi-Fi? across print and online for more than 15 years, writing news, reviews and features. He has covered product launch events across the world, from Apple to Technics, Sony and Samsung, reported from CES, the Bristol Show and Munich High End for many years, and provided comment for sites such as the BBC and the Guardian. In his spare time he enjoys mixing vinyl and cycling.

  • manicm
    The only high res streaming option I’d consider is MQA , so from Tidal.

    I think Spotify are right to cap it at cd quality.
    Reply
  • HisDudeness
    Spotify might be late to the party when compared to the other streaming services, but none of the services that I have tried are even remotely close to the ease of use of Spotify. Recommendations work, automatic playlists/song based radio stations work fantastic, the app is great, Spotify Connect just works and is widely available... In my opinion the Spotify ecosystem is unbeatable right now.

    Tidal might have MQA, but I always wonder what the source material is. Same goes for Qobuz high res streaming. It might have a shiny jacket and a cool label, but the quality of the source material might still be poop.

    Additionally, in my experience the music that I really enjoy is rarely available in a quality above CD level. So I'm looking forward to Spotify HiFi and whether it will make a difference on my B&W 603 paired with Yamaha R-N803D. I assume that my Yamaha will automatically use the highest available bitrate.
    Reply
  • pacco65
    For me, Spotify has the edge because of Spotify connect. That's why i chose Spotify over Apple music and Amazon. I'd rather listen at 320bps on Spotify than CD quality on Amazon, for instance, without that functionality.
    Reply