Pro-Ject Essential III review

Pro-Ject can’t shake the habit of turning out top-class turntables...

What Hi-Fi? Verdict

Another excellent Pro-Ject turntable with a tempting upgrade option


  • +

    Smart styling

  • +

    Relatively simple set-up

  • +

    Open, detailed sound

  • +

    Exciting treble


  • -

    Build isn’t rock solid

Why you can trust What Hi-Fi? Our expert team reviews products in dedicated test rooms, to help you make the best choice for your budget. Find out more about how we test.

For a small but loyal band of music lovers, vinyl is well and truly back on the menu – and turntable manufacturers are doing their best to make hay while the sun shines. Pro-Ject is one such brand.

A relative newcomer, the company has made its presence felt with an unrivalled stream of four- and five-star turntables over the last 20 years. The Pro-Ject Essential III is the latest addition to the roster.

The first Pro-Ject Essential range first appeared at the turn of the decade and went on to take home multiple five-star reviews and What Hi-Fi? Awards. This third incarnation has been four years in the making and joins a sub-£300 turntable market that’s more crowded than ever.

Pro-Ject now has two models below the Essential – the Elemental (£150) and Primary (£190) – but calls the £240 Essential III “the first true hi-fi offering”. Luckily, the Essential III has plenty to offer.

Build and features

Four years is a long time and, sure enough, there have been a host of upgrades. The platter and plinth are now MDF rather than chipboard – as is the case on plenty of far more expensive decks – while the cartridge and cables have also been upgraded, with the Ortofon OM10 on board here.

From the pulley to the spindle bearings, the motor electronics to a new grounding link – Pro-Ject has gone to town on the tweaks.

A belt-drive deck remains a relatively simple machine and while it’s not quite as easy to get started as some budget turntables, the little work required should be straightforward, dare we even say enjoyable, for the average vinyl enthusiast.

MORE: How to set up a turntable

Just put the platter in place and feed the belt around it. Manually switch the belt between the inner and outer ring of the pulley to select 33 or 45 rpm.

Adjusting the counterweight to balance the cartridge is a little fiddly, while the anti-skating thread seems fussy, but follow the instructions and you’ll be spinning records well within half an hour of unboxing.

And the result is a turntable that certainly looks better than a budget deck, even if the lightweight feel of the deck and tonearm is more in tune with its price.

MORE: How a turntable is made


Place a record on the platter – a mat is optional and there isn’t one included – and you’ll soon be treated to the trademark Pro-Ject sound. This is a good thing.

Listening to Stetsasonic’s Talkin' All That Jazz is easy and enjoyable, thanks to good dynamics, an exciting treble, and a sonic balance that’s on the bright side but never edgy.

Dial it down a notch with Carl Orff’s Carmina Burana and the Essential III does an impressive job of placing instruments in the room, while showing decent scale and an open soundstage. What’s not to like? Very little.

MORE: Best turntables 2017

That is until we involve the Rega Planar 1, our sub-£300 Award-winner.

There’s not much in it but the Rega does time a little better, skipping along at a pace that forces your toe to tap, while also delivering a better-organised, fuller-bodied sound.

Laurent Garnier’s The Man With The Red Face affirms this in a matter of revolutions. Different strokes for different folks? Absolutely. We’d lean towards the Rega but we’d recommend hearing both.

MORE: How to get the best sound from your turntable

But there’s a twist. Also in Pro-Ject’s arsenal is the Essential III A. That ‘A’ refers to an acrylic platter upgrade (called the Pro-Ject Acryl-IT E). The A turntable costs an extra £40 – but it’s money well spent.

The sound is instantly bigger and more open, while bass notes are firmer for a more rounded presentation. And there’s an extra layer of detail for good measure. The Essential III A and the Rega P1 are definitely something of a toss-up.

MORE: 10 affordable ways to upgrade your hi-fi system


Another budget Pro-Ject turntable, another five-star review – the company simply can’t shake the habit of turning out top-class turntables. Just save up for the acrylic platter if you can…

See all our Pro-Ject reviews

What Hi-Fi?

What Hi-Fi?, founded in 1976, is the world's leading independent guide to buying and owning hi-fi and home entertainment products. Our comprehensive tests help you buy the very best for your money, with our advice sections giving you step-by-step information on how to get even more from your music and movies. Everything is tested by our dedicated team of in-house reviewers in our custom-built test rooms in London, Reading and Bath. Our coveted five-star rating and Awards are recognised all over the world as the ultimate seal of approval, so you can buy with absolute confidence.

Read more about how we test