Audio Analogue Maestro review

This special edition CD player puts analysis, authority and dynamics on its hit-list Tested at £4300.00

What Hi-Fi? Verdict

It might lack the last ounce of fun, but the Maestro SE is still a classy choice


  • +

    Impressive build and finish

  • +

    sonic authority and refinement

  • +

    composed nature


  • -

    Terrible remote

  • -

    confusing menus

  • -

    limited choice of digital inputs

Why you can trust What Hi-Fi? Our expert team reviews products in dedicated test rooms, to help you make the best choice for your budget. Find out more about how we test.

Audio Analogue has something of an uneven track record with us. Its more affordable products have been a little hit and miss over the years, with true superstars like the original Puccini SE integrated amplifier (from around a decade or so ago) being in a distinct minority.

Yet, in recent times the company has started to attack the high-end market – with considerable success – with its Class A integrated amp and pre/monobloc combination. The latter leaves little change from £20k, mind.

It's from this DNA that the Maestro SE CD player emerges. This chunky machine might share its name with some less-than-distinguished spinners, but it's a far more serious effort than the company has attempted before.

First impressions are almost all positive. The player looks elegant and expensive – just the way most high-end buyers like it.

There are neat flourishes such as the imaginative control button layout on the front panel, and there's little wrong with the large, clear display.

The only bit of bad news is the downmarket remote control: there's really no excuse at this price level.

Connection options could be better
The player's connections are par for this class, bar an important extra. Analogue outputs include the standard balanced XLR and unbalanced RCA. Digitally, there's coaxial in and out.

While the digital input will accept signals up to 24bit/192kHz, limiting it to coaxial is a strange choice. Optical and USB would have been more useful, and extended the Maestro's compatibility to a wider range of sources. It's a shame, as the on-board DAC is far better than that used in most conventional products.

We like this player, we really do. But why does Audio Analogue have to make it so complicated to optimise?

Delve into the Maestro's set-up menus (yes this is a CD player with set-up menus), and there are tweaks aplenty.

You can start with PLL mode, which cleans up the internal clock (shouldn't this be standard?). In this mode you can also upsample from CD's 44.1kHz all the way to 176.4kHz, with a step of 88.2kHz in between.

If you decide to bypass the PLL option and go to SRC (Sample Rate Conversion) mode, the options are – take a deep breath – 44.1kHz, 48kHz, 88.2kHz, 96kHz, 176.4kHz and 192kHz.

Experiment with the settings
Confused? We don't blame you. The two modes are similar, and while the ability to fine-tune is welcome, it can get confusing.

Our favourite was PLL on with the sampling rate set to 44.1kHz – it gave the best compromise between refinement and attack with our Bryston/ATC reference system. Oh, and switch off the digital output. The sound is crisper and more refined if you do.

So, how does the Maestro SE sound? Oddly, pretty much as it looks. The presentation is large-scale and authoritative, and sounds excellent with complex classical such as Beethoven's Fifth Symphony, where
its slam, refinement and insight come to the fore.

It paints a broad, nicely-distanced sound stage and gets tonality just right. Complexity is no problem, either: it sounds composed no matter how simple or intricate things get. Detail is good rather than great, but there's little here to spoil our fun.

Rhythm is gonna get you
The Maestro doesn't get tripped up by fast rhythms either, unlike some past Audio Analogue products.

It has the drive to make Major Lazer's Guns Don't Kill People…Lazers Do a real experience, and that's something many high-end machines, for all their resolution and obvious skill, sometimes fail to do.

Switch to the Award-winning Cyrus CD XT SE+/DAC X+/PSX-R x2 combo, available for similar money, and you'll get even more snap, but the Maestro isn't far behind.

This player is easy to underestimate. For all its scale and power it's a machine that doesn't knock your socks off, but give it time and it's a fine contender.

See all our CD player Best Buys

Follow on Twitter

Join on Facebook

What Hi-Fi?

What Hi-Fi?, founded in 1976, is the world's leading independent guide to buying and owning hi-fi and home entertainment products. Our comprehensive tests help you buy the very best for your money, with our advice sections giving you step-by-step information on how to get even more from your music and movies. Everything is tested by our dedicated team of in-house reviewers in our custom-built test rooms in London, Reading and Bath. Our coveted five-star rating and Awards are recognised all over the world as the ultimate seal of approval, so you can buy with absolute confidence.

Read more about how we test