Nine people sit in a low-lit room. A Radiohead fans' support group.
"I'm Paul, and I preferred Radiohead's early work." Applause.
"I think Kid A is a bit weird." More applause.
"We all did, Paul."
"Personally, between you and me, I thought OK Computer was a bit overrated."
"...Get out."
Yes, this is a BBC Comedy sketch, but how dare anyone dislike OK Computer ? It's just about the one thing all Radiohead fans ought to be able to agree on.
Nevertheless, fan or not, there is little argument to be made against its influence. To illustrate that, and on the release of the 20th anniversary edition, OK Computer OKNOTOK 1997-2017, we take a look at some of the best cover versions, all of which will do a decent job of stretching your music system.
Doveman – Airbag
If you've not heard of Doveman, real name Thomas Bartlett, you're still likely to be aware of some of his work: he produced Sufjan Stevens's Carrie & Lowell and The Magnetic Fields' 50 Song Memoir, and features on tracks by David Byrne, The National, Antony & The Johnsons and Father John Misty.
He covered Airbag, OK Computer's opening track, as part of a compilation put together by Stereogum to celebrate the album's 10th anniversary. In contrast to the decidedly more raucous original, Doveman creates a more restrained, pensive atmosphere, not dissimilar to some of his work with collaborator Sufjan Stevens.
Download Doveman's version of Airbag free from Stereogum
Brad Mehldau – Paranoid Android
Jazz pianist Brad Mehldau's arrangment of Paranoid Android found its way on to his record Largo, and, while its freak-out section isn't quite as ear-splitting as the original, it holds its own in terms of tonal experimentation.
For fans of solo piano, Mehldau released a live record, performed in Tokyo, where this particular track is just 30 seconds shy of 20 minutes. And you thought the six-and-a-half-minute original was epic ...
Listen to Brad Mehldau's version of Paranoid Android on Spotify or a live version on Tidal
Find Brad Mehldau Largo on Amazon
Christopher O'Riley – Subterranean Homesick Alien
More piano, but this time classical rather than jazz. American pianist Christopher O'Riley's work spans the Baroque period to reinventions of modern popular works. Concerning the latter, he's left his personal touch on compositions by Pink Floyd, Elliot Smith, Nirvana and, of course, Radiohead.
O'Riley released collections of Radiohead covers in 2003 and 2005, with tracks from OK Computer on each, and we think Subterranean Homesick Alien, included on 2003's True Love Waits (Christopher O'Riley Plays Radiohead), works particularly well as a classical piece.
Listen to Christopher O'Riley's version of Subterranean Homesick Alien on Spotify and Tidal
Find True Love Waits (Christopher O'Riley Plays Radiohead) on Amazon
Vampire Weekend – Exit Music (For A Film)
Exit Music (For A Film) has been scientifically proven to be Radiohead's sixth most depressing song. With this version, another track from Stereogum's 10th anniversary ode to the record, you may then be surprised they got Vampire Weekend to cover it.
But what this left-field marriage of artist and source material does allow for is a near total reinvention. There's no getting away from the tonality and lyrics that earn Exit Music its spot in the band's sombre top ten, but Vampire Weekend weave in typically angular rhythms for a version that almost makes you want to dance.
Download Vampire Weekend's version of Exit Music (For A Film) free from Stereogum
Scala & Kolacny Brothers – Exit Music (For A Film)
But if Vampire Weekend manage to subvert Exit Music (For A Film)'s dark atmosphere, this version by Belgian women's choir Scala & Kolacny Brothers somehow makes it even more haunting.
Arranged and accompanied by pianist Steven Kolacny, there's an eerie sense of space and a vulnerability to the vocal performance. If it's "for a film", then this cover version sounds perfect for a gothic horror.
Listen to Scala & Kolacny Brothers' version of Exit Music (For A Film) on Spotify and Tidal
Find Scala & Kolacny Brothers Dream On on Amazon
The Bad Plus – Karma Police
Featured on another Radiohead covers compilation, this one entitled Exit Music: Songs With Radio Heads, it's interesting to hear avante-garde jazz trio The Bad Plus covering what is arguably OK Computer's most radio-friendly pop track.
Unsurprisingly, it isn't so radio-friendly by the time they've finished with it. It's three minutes longer than the original, accounted for largely by a meandering free-form interlude between the main body of the song and that closing hook.
Listen to The Bad Plus's version of Karma Police on Spotify and Tidal
Find Exit Music: Songs With Radio Heads on Amazon
The Twilight Sad – Climbing Up The Walls
While a lot of these covers are in shouldn't-work-but-somehow-does territory, The Twilight Sad covering Climbing Up The Walls was never really in doubt. If you didn't already know the song from OK Computer, it could quite happily masquerade as one of the Scottish trio's own.
The third and final track we've included from Stereogum's covers tribute, it sounds like the original but with grazed knees from having been dragged across the gravel. If your system fails to capture any emotion from this performance, you might need to have a rethink.
Download The Twilight Sad's version of Climbing Up The Walls free from Stereogum
Marcus Intalex – Climbing Up The Walls
We're fairly convinced that Climbing Up The Walls, alongside Exit Music (For A Film), is a song so good it's simply impossible for anyone to make it sound bad. Certainly, a producer of the calibre of Marcus Intalex wasn't going to let us down.
The dance music pioneer, who sadly passed away earlier this year, included this version on his 2011 release 21. Given Radiohead's subsequent embrace of electronic music, this version almost acts as a sketch of how the track might have sounded were it written later in Radiohead's career.
Listen to Marcus Intalex's version of Climbing Up The Walls on Spotify and Tidal
Find Marcus Intalex 21 on Amazon
Regina Spektor – No Surprises
There's little to say about Regina Spektor's cover of No Surprises, other than it was released in 2010 as a charity single, with proceeds going to the Doctors Without Borders Emergency Relief Fund, and it's mesmerisingly beautiful.
Listen to Regina Spektor's version of No Surprises on Spotify and Tidal
Download Regina Spektor No Surprises from Amazon
Easy Star All-Stars – Radiodread
If the mere mention of Radiohead brings to mind an image of sobbing orphans in the bleak midwinter, allow Easy Star All-Stars to alter your perception.
Probably our favourite of the group's dub-inspired covers records, Radiodread is a track-by-track reinvention of OK Computer, featuring veritable roots legends from Horace Andy to Toots & The Maytals.
Listen to Easy Star All-Stars Radiodread on Spotify and Tidal
Find Easy Star All-Stars Radiodread on Amazon
Radiohead – No Surprises (800% slower)
If Radiohead are releasing bonus material on OKNOTOK, then why on earth shouldn't we?
There are a bunch of these slowed down versions of the band's tunes on YouTube - Pyramid Song and How To Disappear Completely are equally beautiful - and even Justin Bieber is full of ambient delights when heard at this speed.
Download the 'Paulstretch' software and you can even create your own ambient cover of your favourite OK Computer cut...
Read more:
Listen to the What Hi-Fi? playlist
50 of the best audiophile albums
12 of the best vinyl test records
Watch a needle on a vinyl record in microscopic detail