When you buy a piece of vinyl, you can be certain of a couple of things. First, it's going to sound better than the version available on streaming. And second, it's yours forever, and won't be taken away from you due to a change in licensing agreements.
But if you assumed your 12-inch would contain all the same tracks – with all the same elements – as the streaming version, then we have bad news for you.
Because recently, vinyl albums have been dropping with glaring omissions, including elements of tracks missing, unfinished mixes, and even entire songs absent. Meaning that the lower-quality version you'll get via streaming services is actually superior in some respects.
Understandably, fans are pretty miffed. And the record labels could be doing a lot more to prevent these mistakes from happening, or at least to communicate to fans that the version they're buying is going to be different.
Should do better
The Guardian recently documented cases of this happening, and it's all mainstream artists from big labels who really should do better: Raye, Charli xcx, Olivia Rodrigo, The Weeknd. It's not just a recent phenomenon: the first vinyl pressings of Beyonce's 2024 album Cowboy Carter were missing five tracks that appeared in its digital incarnation, while other albums (like Lil Wayne's Tha Carter VI) were released in much shorter vinyl versions than on digital.
Why is this happening? It's not just ineptitude on the part of the labels, though that does play a part. Vinyl pressing plants need information like artwork and audio masters from the labels weeks ahead of the album's release date in order to guarantee the place in the queue. The Guardian piece quotes six to eight weeks, but an industry source tells us lead times of eight to 10 weeks are more common at the moment.
That means any last-minute changes – or even entirely new mixes created during those weeks – will miss the cut-off.
Streaming services, by contrast, only need around five days to upload digital files for the audio, artwork and promotional materials.
Another reason is cost. Deluxe double- and even triple-albums cost a lot to release on vinyl, not only because they involve more 12-inch records, but also due to the premium packaging. Though you would think the higher asking price would cover that.
Be careful what you buy
Now obviously it's down to the artists and labels to hit their deadlines, and to make sure they're happy with the finished product before sending it off. Admittedly that can be trickier when it comes to collaborations, as it involves aligning the diaries of lots of very busy people (filmmaker David Cronenberg's contribution to Charlie xcx's album Music, Fashion, Film was one of the most egregious omissions from a vinyl version in recent memory). But that's no excuse.
And if there are omissions from the vinyl album, fans deserve to know about them before shelling out their hard-earned. Vinyl isn't cheap. A new LP costs around £30. To then find out that you're not even getting the finished article is pretty galling, to say the least.
So what's to be done?
Until record labels become more honest and open about any differences between the physical media and digital versions, not much. You can hold off buying an album on release day and wait to see what other fans report, but that's not ideal. Instead, we would petition your favourite artists and labels to make clear any discrepancies so us punters can make an informed purchasing decision. £30 is a lot to spend on an album only to find out that the 'full' version is free on Spotify at a crappy bitrate.
MORE:
This album was the 1980s poster boy for CD – but I prefer it on vinyl
