Have your say & ask the experts!

Johnny Marr - Vinyl or CD

18 replies [Last post]
stevebrock's picture
Offline
Joined: 13 Nov 2009
Posts: 3627

Has anybody got it yet?

Obviously a shouty record, just wondering if the Vinyl is worth the investment over the CD in terms of dynamics etc?

I would prefer the vinyl though!

 

__________________

Icon Audio ST40 III / KT88, Rega Apollo R, DAC, RS3

Rega RP6, Nagaoka MP-200, White Belt, Michell Tecnoweight, Rega Fono MM

Rega Quattro, Couple 1 & 2

 

 

 

 

 

rjb70stoke's picture
Offline
Joined: 25 Mar 2010
Posts: 107
RE: Johnny Marr - Vinyl or CD

Spotify first me-thinks, then make a call on getting the vinyl.

Im desperate to try a modern recording on my turntable, but want it to be a really good album. I have high hopes for the Johnny Marr album.

__________________

AV:- Denon AVR-2113 Receiver, Kef 1005.2 speaker package, Apple TV (3rd Gen), PS3 Slim, Sky HD, Panasonic TX-42UT30 TV.

HiFi:- Denon PMA-355UK, Technics SL-1900 turntable, HTPC, Mission 733i speakers.

stevebrock's picture
Offline
Joined: 13 Nov 2009
Posts: 3627
RE: Johnny Marr - Vinyl or CD

rjb70stoke wrote:

Spotify first me-thinks, then make a call on getting the vinyl.

Im desperate to try a modern recording on my turntable, but want it to be a really good album. I have high hopes for the Johnny Marr album.

 

Listening to it all morning on Spotify - I love it, he hasnt got a bad voice and fantastic guitars (but what else would you expect from Marr)

 

 

__________________

Icon Audio ST40 III / KT88, Rega Apollo R, DAC, RS3

Rega RP6, Nagaoka MP-200, White Belt, Michell Tecnoweight, Rega Fono MM

Rega Quattro, Couple 1 & 2

 

 

 

 

 

stevebrock's picture
Offline
Joined: 13 Nov 2009
Posts: 3627
RE: Johnny Marr - Vinyl or CD

I have just gone for it!  Vinyl form Amazon £16.43 delivered

 

__________________

Icon Audio ST40 III / KT88, Rega Apollo R, DAC, RS3

Rega RP6, Nagaoka MP-200, White Belt, Michell Tecnoweight, Rega Fono MM

Rega Quattro, Couple 1 & 2

 

 

 

 

 

Joined: 2 Sep 2007
Posts: 1761
RE: Johnny Marr - Vinyl or CD

stevebrock wrote:

Has anybody got it yet?

Obviously a shouty record, just wondering if the Vinyl is worth the investment over the CD in terms of dynamics etc?

I would prefer the vinyl though!

 

 

Not sure which format. I've been listening to it for a few weeks (a friend furnished me with a pre-release CD-R) and although I'm a lifelong Smiths/ Marr fan, like you no doubt, I was really underwhelmed by it. I was also surprised by how poor it sounded in terms of sound quality. Unless the vinyl bucks the general trend of much newly released vinyl being poor pressings and/or a simple digital transfer, I'd personally not hold out much hope for it. 

 

It pains me to say it of one of my musical heroes but it's a pretty poor record, for me. Great playing, lame vocals, mediocre songs. As noted by someone elsewhere (Pitchfork online review), this would have sounded great in 1994. I agree, it now just sounds uninspiring and hollow. Brittle and brash too, on my system anyway. Even in the car I find myself wincing at the compression and tinny sound when I push the volume upwards. Shame. 

 

I've waited for it to grow on me. Buf it's just not happening.  Maybe it's a case of "has the world changed or have I changed" to quote SPM, but it doesn't do much for me. 

__________________

Roksan Caspian Pre amp, Caspian Mono Power amp x 2, NAD M51 DAC, B&W 805 Signature, Roksan Radius turntable, Denon-1713UD, MF phono & headphone amps, PS3, Mac/AE/Apple TV

stevebrock's picture
Offline
Joined: 13 Nov 2009
Posts: 3627
RE: Johnny Marr - Vinyl or CD

Charlie,

Thats what I didnt want to hear!

O god why cant these mastering engineers sort their rubbish out?

Why cant records sound like they did in the 80s as an example I picked up a copy of Latin Quarter - Modern Times.... what an absolutely fantastic sounding/produced LP

__________________

Icon Audio ST40 III / KT88, Rega Apollo R, DAC, RS3

Rega RP6, Nagaoka MP-200, White Belt, Michell Tecnoweight, Rega Fono MM

Rega Quattro, Couple 1 & 2

 

 

 

 

 

Joined: 2 Sep 2007
Posts: 1761
RE: Johnny Marr - Vinyl or CD

stevebrock wrote:

Charlie,

Thats what I didnt want to hear!

O god why cant these mastering engineers sort their rubbish out?

Why cant records sound like they did in the 80s as an example I picked up a copy of Latin Quarter - Modern Times.... what an absolutely fantastic sounding/produced LP

__________________

Roksan Caspian Pre amp, Caspian Mono Power amp x 2, NAD M51 DAC, B&W 805 Signature, Roksan Radius turntable, Denon-1713UD, MF phono & headphone amps, PS3, Mac/AE/Apple TV

BigH's picture
Offline
Joined: 29 Dec 2012
Posts: 3300
RE: Johnny Marr - Vinyl or CD

stevebrock wrote:

Charlie,

Thats what I didnt want to hear!

O god why cant these mastering engineers sort their rubbish out?

Why cant records sound like they did in the 80s as an example I picked up a copy of Latin Quarter - Modern Times.... what an absolutely fantastic sounding/produced LP

 

Its the record companies who think loud sells more, maybe it does in the mp3 market but its no good for hifi. Just listening to it on spotify don't think I will be buying it but its OK. I stopped buying LPs in the 80s due to poor quality, scatches etc. The early 70s ones were much better, thicker, less scratches.

 

Modern Times sounds a bit lightweight.

Joined: 2 Sep 2007
Posts: 1761
RE: Johnny Marr - Vinyl or CD

Hi Steve,

 

I don't know what happened to my reply but it went something like this:

 

I hope it was the fault of my CD-R, and that the vinyl does improve things. 

Have you made any progress with Elvis Costello?

__________________

Roksan Caspian Pre amp, Caspian Mono Power amp x 2, NAD M51 DAC, B&W 805 Signature, Roksan Radius turntable, Denon-1713UD, MF phono & headphone amps, PS3, Mac/AE/Apple TV

stevebrock's picture
Offline
Joined: 13 Nov 2009
Posts: 3627
RE: Johnny Marr - Vinyl or CD

Charlie Jefferson wrote:

Hi Steve,

 

I don't know what happened to my reply but it went something like this:

 

I hope it was the fault of my CD-R, and that the vinyl does improve things. 

Have you made any progress with Elvis Costello?

Well Ive order the Marr record!

Im popping into town later today, so will stop by at the record shop and see what Costello he has...normally £2-5 and mostly in excellent nick!

 

__________________

Icon Audio ST40 III / KT88, Rega Apollo R, DAC, RS3

Rega RP6, Nagaoka MP-200, White Belt, Michell Tecnoweight, Rega Fono MM

Rega Quattro, Couple 1 & 2

 

 

 

 

 

theadmans's picture
Offline
Joined: 4 Jun 2009
Posts: 70
RE: Johnny Marr - Vinyl or CD

I have read somewhere that DR (Dynamic Range) rating for this new album is only 6.

 

If this is true then this album is yet another casuality of the Loudness Wars (when will this madness end)  Angry

 

At DR = 6 I think I will settle for listening on Spotify Premium - certainly wouldn't waste any more money on what is clearly a poorly mastered release.

 

BigH's picture
Offline
Joined: 29 Dec 2012
Posts: 3300
RE: Johnny Marr - Vinyl or CD

theadmans wrote:

I have read somewhere that DR (Dynamic Range) rating for this new album is only 6.

 

If this is true then this album is yet another casuality of the Loudness Wars (when will this madness end)  Angry

 

At DR = 6 I think I will settle for listening on Spotify Premium - certainly wouldn't waste any more money on what is clearly a poorly mastered release.

 

 

You read right, it is 6, presume that is for cd.

 

Top Rock/Pop cd is Steve Earle's Copperhead Road at 19, his Jerusalem is only 6.

stevebrock's picture
Offline
Joined: 13 Nov 2009
Posts: 3627
RE: Johnny Marr - Vinyl or CD

It really is a tragic situation with all this poorly mastered music that's had the rubbish kicked out of the dynamics! 

I am at a loss with now - surely the artists aren't happy about this stupid needless situation!

Yes we expect it (but we shouldn't) with chart music for the iPod generation but this is beyond a joke! 

__________________

Icon Audio ST40 III / KT88, Rega Apollo R, DAC, RS3

Rega RP6, Nagaoka MP-200, White Belt, Michell Tecnoweight, Rega Fono MM

Rega Quattro, Couple 1 & 2

 

 

 

 

 

stevebrock's picture
Offline
Joined: 13 Nov 2009
Posts: 3627
RE: Johnny Marr - Vinyl or CD

I'm off to listen to some nicely mastered 70/80s vinyl!

__________________

Icon Audio ST40 III / KT88, Rega Apollo R, DAC, RS3

Rega RP6, Nagaoka MP-200, White Belt, Michell Tecnoweight, Rega Fono MM

Rega Quattro, Couple 1 & 2

 

 

 

 

 

BigH's picture
Offline
Joined: 29 Dec 2012
Posts: 3300
RE: Johnny Marr - Vinyl or CD

Steven Wilson: The Raven That Refused to Sing

 

This appears to be somewhat better if that is your cup of tea, talking of which must have one.

rjb70stoke's picture
Offline
Joined: 25 Mar 2010
Posts: 107
RE: Johnny Marr - Vinyl or CD

Steve,

Im with you about the album. Not a great but Im loving the New Order feel to many of the tracks.

Having read what I presume to be your conversation on Amazon, Ive gone ahead and ordered the vinyl. Lets just hope that Stacy hasnt let us down, with her comments.

__________________

AV:- Denon AVR-2113 Receiver, Kef 1005.2 speaker package, Apple TV (3rd Gen), PS3 Slim, Sky HD, Panasonic TX-42UT30 TV.

HiFi:- Denon PMA-355UK, Technics SL-1900 turntable, HTPC, Mission 733i speakers.