Sounds like the dirty screen effect on your GT50 is toward the more tolerable end of the spectrum. Now you've identified the cause of the yellow blobs and found a workaround, I can understand your decision to stick rather than twist.
By running slides, they're not talking about the scrolling bar, rather a sequence of slides designed to break the panel in evenly. You could reasonably argue that using a new plasma TV responsibly is just as effective. Besides, I'm guessing you're past the "panic" stage, as your set has been in use for a month.
I'm intrigued to know, do you think the dirty screen effect has become less noticeable as your GT50 has bedded in?
I'd say the issue on my GT50 is pretty comparable with the photograph uploaded to that thread.
I'm watching the football and I always see the dirty screen effect with camera pans. There are a couple of lighter lines, roughly an inch thick, about three inches from the right-side bezel. It's frustrating, as I think the picture is fantastic otherwise.
If I thought things would improve, I could live with the problem short-term. I've been watching BBC HD tonight and the picture was fantastic the majority of the time. I was mostly watching documentaries, though, with lots of static shots.
I'm watching football now, the dse is only noticeable during camera pans, and really only noticeable if I look towards the right hand side of the screen. I've never noticed it during any other viewing, only with camera pans during sports with a green solid background.
I don't think the dse has lessened over time, I just try to forget about it, not get drawn to it.
If you can see yours while just normally watching the tv, then I think you should change it again, if it's only when you look to that side of the screen, then stick with it.
Saying that, after being 100% certain last night that I would keep this one, the doubts have again risen in my mind.
What if the next one is perfect?
What if the next one is worse?
It's driving me mad, but I have to make a decision very soon, the replacement is due Tuesday morning. " />
(Amp is on the backburner until this is sorted.)
LOUNGE: Panasonic TX-P50GT50 (is poorly) / Panasonic DMP-BDT120 / Yamaha RX-A2020 / Q Acoustics 2020i (front) / Q Acoustics 2020 (rear) / Q Acoustics 2000Ci / Q Acoustics1000Si / Roksan Radius 5.2 (is poorly, so Pro-ject Debut III) / Sky HD / WD My Book Live / Tacima CS-929
BEDROOM: Samsung LE32C450 / Sony BDP-S360 / Echostar HDS-600RS / Netgear WNCE2001
No issues here with the VT50.......
Panasonic VT50B / Pioneer VSX- LX55 / SKY+ HD 2TB / Sony BD370 / Tannoy Arena 5.1 / Dual CS506 / Isotek MIRA / QED Cables
There are a number of threads on other forums, where users have described image retention & screen burn.
Besides, the same problem (DSE) is prevalent in VT50 as well, as it's "within manufacturer's specification". Some people notice it more than others.
Check this thread, for example:
"We'll all have some imperfect uniformity on grey/white slides, but this is due to DSE- not IR. All VT50's have some level of DSE thanks to the "Kuro-like filter""
And user comments here:
"I'm now on my second Panasonic VT50 and will have to return this one too. The first one had terrible burn in"
My Home Cinema Pioneer KRP 500A, Yamaha RX-V1900, MA Radius R225HD LCR, R90HD rears, AW12 sub, Panasonic BD60, PS3, Boxee Box, Sky HD, Boxee Box, Logitech Harmony One, Logitech PS3 Adapter, Sonos ZP90
Bedroom Samsung UE32C6510, PS3 slim white, Apple TV, Sonos S5, Sonos ZP90, Audioengine 2, Oppo OPDV971H
Miscellaneous: Synology DS212J + 2 X WD Red 2TB drives, WD 1TB NAS, Sonos ZoneBridge, BT HH3 as modem & AirPort Extreme router
I can only comment on my own experience. As for burn in and image retention, proper running in on low contrast and brightness settings is essential. It is unfortunately Plasma's achilles heel, and to be fair Pioneer were worse in this respect than the more modern Pannys.
That's good that your TV is free from these issues, like a lot of happy GT50 owners as well. I agree regarding the importance of proper running in, although IR / screen burn isn't so much of an issue now. I was, in fact, surprised that a 2012 model exhibited this problem. Maybe it was the Olympics logo.
I can't say for the previous generations, but my 9th generation Pioneer never showed any IR or screen burn despite hours of gaming at a time. At the time (2009), Samsung and LG plasmas were notorious for IR and screen burn and Pioneer & Panasonic were considered to be the best in this regard.
After being 100% certain last night that I would keep this one, the doubts have again risen in my mind.
I'm only basing my response on experience of two GT50s, but I'd say any differences between them were very small, if indeed there's any difference at all.
I've read too much about this to believe there's a perfect GT50 out there (or ST or VT). I'm guessing users that report a "perfect" set are less distracted by the issue, or use settings that mask it reasonably well.
I don't notice the bands on the majority of content, but I always see them when watching football (blocks of grey and green show them up most visibly).
If you've any way of displaying a uniform grey screen, setting the contrast to minimum clearly shows which areas of the set are affected. This doesn't reflect normal viewing, but it perhaps explains why those using high contrast settings see the dirty screen effect less, or not at all (the "normal" picture preset has a higher default contrast setting than other picture modes, with the exception of "dynamic," of course).
I'm no less annoyed by this problem than I was on the first day I became a GT50 owner. Assuming I keep the TV, it will be because I find issues with other TVs more objectionable.
You can give a replacement a shot. I'd be interested to hear how you get on, though I don't want to encourage you to do this for the sake of my curiosity. I'm guessing your experience with a replacement would be remarkably similar to mine.
Hardware: Panasonic TX-P50VT65B (calibrated); Cambridge Audio Azur 651BD; Yamaha RX-A810; Teac PD-H600; PS3; B&W 601 & 600LCR (series 3); Q Acoustics QAV (rear)
Furniture and Accessories: BLOK Classix 3000 Oak AV Cabinet; Atacama Nexus 6 (atabite metal filled); 3D3 A1112
Looks like you should stop watching football, & watch some other sport, like cricket or tennis!
I don't really watch football, but cricket and grass court tennis may be no better. What's most distracting is the knowledge that the problem is there and can show up at any time. Nature documentaries, for instance, often display large patches of green, or pastel skies. Hours of viewing can pass without the bands appearing, but each time they do my enjoyment of the TV diminishes.
I think I would twist.
Main AV Setup: Panasonic 50VT65 TV, Pioneer Bdp-lx71, Pioneer Vsx-lx70, B&W FPM Series, B&W PV1, Optimum AV300 AV Stand, QED Silver Anniversary XT Speaker Cable & Chord Silver Plus HDMI Cables. Gadgets: iPad Air & iPhone 4S.
Happy to report a very good outcome. My TV has been replaced with a problem free one. Excellent service from my local Panasonic Store near Bristol - Thanks guys for sorting it so quickly and professionally.
LanceyBoy got a problem free one, gel got a problem free one, means there are good ones out there.
Think I'm gonna twist, I hope I don't regret it. " />
Or will I? " />
I've been exactly where you are now. I sincerely hope all works out favourably. For what it's worth, I think it's highly unlikely that switching will be catastrophic. In my view, different users have different perceptions of what constitutes a "problem free" set. In other words, I'm probably too pedantic for my own good.
Be sure to let us know how you get on...
I've stuck. I've just rang JL and cancelled the replacement.
I've notched up the contrast a bit, and lowered the brightness a touch, and it seems better.
I was watching football and American football last night, and some cricket and golf this morning, and I can barely see the dse, so I can't believe the replacement will be any better.
I was so worried I'd get a real duffer as a replacement, so unless something goes seriously wrong, this is my tv for the next few years.
I'm relieved, and I can now concentrate on getting a new amp.
On the amp side how about this one, a Yamaha was £1500 now £500 ex demo extremely well looked after, cracking amp and comes with shop warranty here:
Milton Keynes shop
That's pretty close to how I feel. I don't think getting another replacement would result in a significant improvement or deterioration; I simply feel it would be more hassle for more of the same.
I also watched the American football last night and hardly noticed the dirty screen effect. That possibly has something to do with the fact that there were fewer fast pans that "actual" football. For the record, the picture is sensational the great majority of the time. Using one of the Professional presets, I now have a picture that looks supremely natural and very punchy.
You could try the following settings. (I know all panels are different, but the THX preset is widely observed to have an excess of green, if very accurate otherwise. The Professional presets replicate colour balance in the THX preset, but allow white and colour balance control.)
White balance: all settings at default, except G-Gain (-7) and G-Cutoff (-9).
I wouldn't suggest for a moment that the picture can't be dialled in more accurately using a colorimeter (I plan to do this in the relatively near future), but images look incredibly natural to me now (and much more so than on any other picture preset).
* The vertical bands are less visible on a uniform grey screen with this contrast setting, which hopefully has a knock-on effect in terms of actual viewing. There's perhaps some minor white clipping using this higher contrast setting.
gel, I think that amp is a little too good for my speakers, I was thinking about the RX-A1020, but that's probably too good too.
My decision will be between the RX-A810, AVR2113 and the STR-DN1030.........probably. " />
Strapped, I've inputted your settings, and it looks quite similar to what I had in CINEMA mode, maybe slightly less bright.
Can I ask you both about settings for watching blu rays?
There are two settings I wanted to check, 1080p Pure Direct, and 24p Smooth Film. What do you have yours set to for these?
© 2013 Haymarket Publishing