What Hi Fi Sound and Vision Thu, 22 Dec 2011, 1:40pm

John Lewis Carbon

Tested at £70
60100
3

Smart looks and a good list of features, but the Carbon’s sound lets it down

Write your own review

For

  • Big display
  • compact dimensions
  • Apple product docking
  • wide-open sound

Against

  • Lack of focus and tonal shortcomings make for an underwhelming listen

With its compact, chunky looks and great big display, the John Lewis Carbon is less just a radio and more like a pricey bedside alarm clock.

But with a spec-list that includes DAB and FM radio reception along with a dock for iPod or iPhone, it’s an authentic and usefully priced alternative to established products.

The Carbon’s speakers are sited at either end of the cabinet and fire in 180˚ opposition to each other. This makes for a remarkably open but ultimately ill-focused sound that’s rather fuzzy and indistinct around the edges.

No single area of performance is fatally flawed, but a combination of rather splashy high frequencies, a shortage of outright detail in the midrange, and overly forward bass makes for a frustrating listening experience.

On the whole, we can’t help thinking the Carbon looks more appealing than it sounds.

Follow whathifi.com on Twitter

Join whathifi.com on Facebook

 

Latest offers