Have your say & ask the experts!

Adele's 'Sky-foal' - verdict?

31 replies [Last post]
f1only's picture
Offline
Joined: 7 Apr 2010
Posts: 1059
RE: Adele's 'Sky-foal' - verdict?

Excellent excellent!

__________________

TV: Sony KDL-46HX853 ( calibrated ), Virgin Tivo Box, BD Players: Sony BDP-S790,  PS3, PS4 & Panasonic DMR-BWT700

A/V Amp: Yamaha RX-V1073

Speakers: Dali Ikon 6 Front L/R, Dali Ikon 1's Surround, Dali Ikon Vocal 2 Centre, B&W ASW610 Subwoofer.

My System

Sony Bravia 46HX853 Calibrated Settings

Sliced Bread's picture
Offline
Joined: 28 Jul 2010
Posts: 1390
RE: Adele's 'Sky-foal' - verdict?

MajorFubar wrote:

Wish I could hear whatever it is about her voice that huge swathes of people rave about. Just '21' alone has gone 16x platinum, let alone sales of '19' and the singles.  But why do I just not hear what all those people hear?

Ok she's not so much of a wailer and warbler from the Mariah Carey or Whitney Houston school of singing (singers like that irritate me even more), but I just don't see how her voice is so 'made-in-heaven' like her many disciples say it is.

Give me someone like Karen Carpenter, Diana Ross, Dusty Springfield, Ella Fitzgerald....

From recent years I'd much rather hear Rumer, Caro Emerald, Nora Jones....

Obviously I am in a minority.

 

I felt exactly the same until I watched the Adele 21 live at the abbot hall performance on Bluray.  Her live performance was far more soulful than the 21 cd.I'm converted now and love her music.

__________________

Samsung PS50Q96HD (Screen) | CA 640c V2 (CD) | Pioneer BDP 320 (BluRay) | Onkyo 905 (Amp) | B&W CM8, CMC & CM1 (Speakers) | MA RS-12 (Sub) | Chord Odyssey 4 (Speaker Cable) | Van den Hul - The Name (Interconnects)

The_Lhc's picture
Offline
Joined: 16 Oct 2008
Posts: 12590
RE: Adele's 'Sky-foal' - verdict?

v1c wrote:
I've read elsewhere some fan's recon that MUSE's new track Supremacy should have been used, at the moment i tend to agree.

Hardly surprising given one section of the strings is actually playing the Bond theme, I was listening to it again this morning.

v1c
v1c's picture
Offline
Joined: 8 Feb 2009
Posts: 688
RE: Adele's 'Sky-foal' - verdict?

The_Lhc wrote:

Hardly surprising given one section of the strings is actually playing the Bond theme, I was listening to it again this morning.

Yes and to cement the point a  bit of chatter about it on the later live Jools Holland rendition Smile

__________________

Pioneer :- KRP500A, BDP LX55, SCLX-71/

MK Sound :- M7 LCR, M4T rear, KX12 sub/

Chord :- Odyssey 2 LCR, Rumour 2 rear, Cobra  sub, Active Silverplus HDMI x2, Power Chord x4, Chameleon Silverplus/ IR dock

Arcam :- IRDock / Focal Lab :- Spirit One/

Black Rhodium Power Management.

v1c
v1c's picture
Offline
Joined: 8 Feb 2009
Posts: 688
RE: Adele's 'Sky-foal' - verdict?

Well found an unofficial trailer for each version

Adele

Muse

Which sits best ?

__________________

Pioneer :- KRP500A, BDP LX55, SCLX-71/

MK Sound :- M7 LCR, M4T rear, KX12 sub/

Chord :- Odyssey 2 LCR, Rumour 2 rear, Cobra  sub, Active Silverplus HDMI x2, Power Chord x4, Chameleon Silverplus/ IR dock

Arcam :- IRDock / Focal Lab :- Spirit One/

Black Rhodium Power Management.

Paul.'s picture
Online
Joined: 26 Nov 2010
Posts: 2842
RE: Adele's 'Sky-foal' - verdict?

Hmm, I would say the Adele track sits better than the Muse one.  I don't think the Muse track is powerful enough, something like Citizen Erased maybe? 3:30 onwards, Citezen Erased has the stones but isn't Bond enough...

__________________

Paul's system thread

(where the photos live) Paul's Flickr page

The_Lhc's picture
Offline
Joined: 16 Oct 2008
Posts: 12590
RE: Adele's 'Sky-foal' - verdict?

Paul Hobbs wrote:
Hmm, I would say the Adele track sits better than the Muse one.  I don't think the Muse track is powerful enough

Eh? Did you have the sound switched on? 

Paul.'s picture
Online
Joined: 26 Nov 2010
Posts: 2842
RE: Adele's 'Sky-foal' - verdict?

I expect more from Muse, the hook is weak.  I don't much like the Adele track, but at least the crescendo fits the ad.

 

The teaser trailer is much better than both of the above.

__________________

Paul's system thread

(where the photos live) Paul's Flickr page

The_Lhc's picture
Offline
Joined: 16 Oct 2008
Posts: 12590
RE: Adele's 'Sky-foal' - verdict?

Paul Hobbs wrote:
I expect more from Muse,

I'm struggling to work out how much "more" Muse can stick in a song without exploding, I mean the current album's even got a Cylon on it...

Quote:
I don't much like the Adele track, but at least the crescendo fits the ad.

I haven't heard it in full or in anything like reasonable quality but it just doesn't seem to fit the brief, the orchestration is poor, the tune forgettable. And of course the tune isn't written to go with the trailer but with the opening credit sequence, so if the crescendo does fit the ad it's just luck or judicious editing by whoever put it together. Either way, I thought the Muse version made the trailer look much more exciting, the Adele track really brings it down, particularly at the start.

Quote:
The teaser trailer is much better than both of the above.

You'd kind of hope so, given they were put together by someone in their bedroom (probably).

Paul.'s picture
Online
Joined: 26 Nov 2010
Posts: 2842
RE: Adele's 'Sky-foal' - verdict?

All fair points.  Have no interest in arguing in favour of Adele.  

The_Lhc wrote:

I'm struggling to work out how much "more" Muse can stick in a song without exploding, I mean the current album's even got a Cylon on it...

You have inadvertently nicely summed up my problem with Muse though.  I'm a huge fan of the earlier stuff, but feel they have become a characture of them selves.  They cram so much in, I don't know if its masking the hooks or the hooks just arn't there anymore, but this track just doesn't grab me.  Maybe my nostalgia for the Origins of Symetry tour is clouding my judgement.

 

Obviously this is all subjective blah blah.

__________________

Paul's system thread

(where the photos live) Paul's Flickr page

The_Lhc's picture
Offline
Joined: 16 Oct 2008
Posts: 12590
RE: Adele's 'Sky-foal' - verdict?

I don't really know Muse's back catalog, The Resistance was the first album of theirs I heard, so I've got no preconceptions, I like the fact that it's often completely over the top, I guess it's a bit like the difference between pre and post synth Queen.

OneBoxSystem's picture
Offline
Joined: 10 Jul 2012
Posts: 392
RE: Adele's 'Sky-foal' - verdict?

Muse have lost the plot. I haven't even bothered buying the latest drivel. Shame, but at least they're trying to bravely break out of a mould......

Andrew Everard's picture
Offline
Joined: 30 May 2007
Posts: 29118
RE: Adele's 'Sky-foal' - verdict?
__________________

Audio Editor, Gramophone

Joined: 17 Aug 2009
Posts: 4289
RE: Adele's 'Sky-foal' - verdict?

Andrew Everard wrote:

It's Skyfoaawuh, actually...

Are you issuing a critique of hypercapitalism by way of biblical analogy? Seems awfully Marxist of you, Andrew (if you take out the religious stuff).

I'm inclined to agree. The endlessly accelerating proliferation of "upgrades" gets fatiguing.

__________________

Hardware: Panasonic TX-P50VT65B (calibrated); Cambridge Audio Azur 651BD; Yamaha RX-A810; Teac PD-H600; PS3; B&W 601 & 600LCR (series 3); Q Acoustics QAV (rear)

Furniture and Accessories: BLOK Classix 3000 Oak AV Cabinet; Atacama Nexus 6 (atabite metal filled); 3D3 A1112

Andrew Everard's picture
Offline
Joined: 30 May 2007
Posts: 29118
RE: Adele's 'Sky-foal' - verdict?

strapped for cash wrote:
Seems awfully Marxist of you, Andrew

__________________

Audio Editor, Gramophone