Have your say & ask the experts!

worth changing from Neat Motive 3 to EB2?

5 replies [Last post]
ByronWarwick
ByronWarwick's picture
Offline
Joined: 21 Jul 2007
Posts: 14

I have got this set up for the last three years:

Naim Cd 5i + Nait 5i Amp + Neat Motive 3 speakers + Naim cables and interconnect.

Been very happy about it most of time apart from occasional slight over bright sound from the speakers and slight mess on some really complex music.

Heard a lot of good things about the EB2 speakers lately and I am wondering whether it is worth changing the speakers to EB2s. I have prepared to wait for them if they are really better.

Any opnions on this would be appreciated.

Thanks

poldo
poldo's picture
Offline
Joined: 23 Dec 2009
Posts: 415
RE: worth changing from Neat Motive 3 to EB2?

Maybe more side step? I don't know I like the Neat's never listened to the EB2. 

 

__________________

AVI ADM 9.1 RS - Apple tv - iPod Touch - iPad - Panasonic 50 G20 - Philips BDP 9600

hifilover1979
hifilover1979's picture
Offline
Joined: 21 Dec 2010
Posts: 853
RE: worth changing from Neat Motive 3 to EB2?

Too much of a sideways of not backwards step IMO

 

Both are great speakers but the Neat 3's really have a superb soundstage to them

 

IMO change the cables; I've herard the Naim 5i amp with it's matching CDP and the Rega Apollo CDP with some B&W CM7's, Neat Motive 3's & 2's and some PMC GB1i's using Naims own cables and the Chord Oddyssey 2 speaker cable & Chord ChameleonPlus & a Black Rhodium 'Prelude' speaker cable and they made a lot of difference (a better more rounded soundstage that calmed the top end down and opened up the bottem end more)

 

Do you have an idea of budget; have you thought about stepping up to the likes of the Neat Motive 2's or the PMC GB1i's etc... Even the B&W CM8's would be a good match IMO

__________________

Main system: Marantz CR603 (with Airplay) / M/A BX5's / Chord Odyssey 2. Office: iMAC (with iTunes) / NAD C320BEE / M/A BX1's 'My room': Cyrus StreamXP / XPower amp / x2 PSX-R's / Hark stand / M/A GX100's / Partington stands

ByronWarwick
ByronWarwick's picture
Offline
Joined: 21 Jul 2007
Posts: 14
RE: worth changing from Neat Motive 3 to EB2?

Thanks for all your replies guys. I don't a plan to upgrade the system because if I upgrade the speakers to another class the I would probably want to upgrade the cd and amp to match as well. I am kind of happy with the system apart from the small issues mentioned. Would like to have a change but within the same class, I would be happy with a small upwards step if it gets rid of the over brightness. Since eb2 was reviewed as the top of the class, I wonder anyone has any experience on learning to them. Eb accoustic is in favor of naim component too so it should be a good match. But wonder it would be a little better than my neat and resolve the issues I have. 

plastic penguin
plastic penguin's picture
Offline
Joined: 28 Apr 2008
Posts: 12964
RE: worth changing from Neat Motive 3 to EB2?

ByronWarwick wrote:

Thanks for all your replies guys. I don't a plan to upgrade the system because if I upgrade the speakers to another class the I would probably want to upgrade the cd and amp to match as well. I am kind of happy with the system apart from the small issues mentioned. Would like to have a change but within the same class, I would be happy with a small upwards step if it gets rid of the over brightness. Since eb2 was reviewed as the top of the class, I wonder anyone has any experience on learning to them. Eb accoustic is in favor of naim component too so it should be a good match. But wonder it would be a little better than my neat and resolve the issues I have. 

Neats and Naim are a fabulous match. Hi-fi is all about synergy and Neat, PMC, MonoPulse, Dynaudio are all cracking matches. As an outsider, look at Totem. Only heard the Arro on my Pulse and blew me away.

__________________

Leema Pulse MKII-S; Naim CD5i MKII; Denon TU-260L MKII; MA RS6 speakers; Pro-ject Xpression 1; loads of different cables...

 

Formerly known as plastic penguin

plastic penguin
plastic penguin's picture
Offline
Joined: 28 Apr 2008
Posts: 12964
RE: worth changing from Neat Motive 3 to EB2?

ByronWarwick wrote:

Thanks for all your replies guys. I don't a plan to upgrade the system because if I upgrade the speakers to another class the I would probably want to upgrade the cd and amp to match as well. I am kind of happy with the system apart from the small issues mentioned. Would like to have a change but within the same class, I would be happy with a small upwards step if it gets rid of the over brightness. Since eb2 was reviewed as the top of the class, I wonder anyone has any experience on learning to them. Eb accoustic is in favor of naim component too so it should be a good match. But wonder it would be a little better than my neat and resolve the issues I have. 

Neats and Naim are a fabulous match. Hi-fi is all about synergy and Neat, PMC, MonoPulse, Dynaudio are all cracking matches. As an outsider, look at Totem. Only heard the Arro on my Pulse and blew me away.

__________________

Leema Pulse MKII-S; Naim CD5i MKII; Denon TU-260L MKII; MA RS6 speakers; Pro-ject Xpression 1; loads of different cables...

 

Formerly known as plastic penguin