Have your say & ask the experts!

Please advice: is 30w x2 class A enough to drive ATC SCM19?

25 replies [Last post]
robhifi
robhifi's picture
Offline
Joined: 8 Mar 2013
Posts: 25

Has anybody here tried using either Accuphase e550/560 or MF AMS 35I with ATC SCM19?

Currently, I am using Accuphase C2420 pre and A35 power (also 30w class A) with ATC SCM7.

The bass is a little lacking so I am thinking switching to scm19 instead.

I don't think anybody in this part of the world (I am from Shanghai) actually may have the same Accuphase pre-power combo, so i guess e550/560(also 30wx2) and MF ams35 should the nearest thing to ask.

 

Thanks !!

__________________

Speakers:Spendor SP1/2R2,Sonus Faber Minima Vintage,ATC SCM19,ELAC 203.2, Monitor Audio S2

Amps:Accuphase C-2420, Accuphase A-35,Rotel 1062,NAD 355BEE,Onkyo tx809

Sources:Marantz SA11-S2 , ROTEL 1072,OPPO 93

Projector: Sanyo z2000

Subs: M&K Sub12,Elac 101.2

Room:4.5mx3m with diffusersX4 and bass tubesX4,dedicated

Neuphonix
Neuphonix's picture
Offline
Joined: 20 Apr 2012
Posts: 278
RE: Please advice: is 30w x2 class A enough to drive ATC SCM19?

I'm not familiar with ATC speakers but have owned an AMS35i for a short period. Looking at the specs I'd say that it would drive them fine.

Only issue you might have is getting your hands on one. there were only 50 made & I think that they are all gone.

I bought one last year and had a few problems with it (long story). But when I demanded a brand new one after the second problem they were unable to provide one. So I ended up being traded up to a separate pre/power for a little extra.

Can highly recommend the sound if you can find one though. good luck Smile

PS. Presume you have air-con over there, you'll need it Wink

__________________

MF AMS-Primo / MF AMS-35P / Linn Akurate DS / Focal Utopia Diablos / Krix Epicentrix / Focal Dome 2 / JL Audio Fathom F110 / JL Audio Fathom F112 / Bryston 10B-Sub / Yamaha RX-Z7 / Oppo Nuforce BDP-93 / PS3 / QNAP TS-219P Turbo NAS

robhifi
robhifi's picture
Offline
Joined: 8 Mar 2013
Posts: 25
RE: Please advice: is 30w x2 class A enough to drive ATC SCM19?

Thanks a lot Neu.
I did read the posts regarding your unfortunate encounter with the ams35.
Sad to say,AMS35i is not popular at all here in China.

A35, being 30w class A,is surprisingly not hot at all. That has something to do with the huge heat sinks I guess.

__________________

Speakers:Spendor SP1/2R2,Sonus Faber Minima Vintage,ATC SCM19,ELAC 203.2, Monitor Audio S2

Amps:Accuphase C-2420, Accuphase A-35,Rotel 1062,NAD 355BEE,Onkyo tx809

Sources:Marantz SA11-S2 , ROTEL 1072,OPPO 93

Projector: Sanyo z2000

Subs: M&K Sub12,Elac 101.2

Room:4.5mx3m with diffusersX4 and bass tubesX4,dedicated

CnoEvil
CnoEvil's picture
Offline
Joined: 21 Aug 2009
Posts: 8774
RE: Please advice: is 30w x2 class A enough to drive ATC SCM19?

As you are probably well aware, I also own the 35i, which is the best amp under £10k that I've heard.........ideally, it likes speakers of high sensitivity (90 dB+) and low impedance, to get the most from it's doubling of power as impedance halves. This will be the case with most Class A.

The Sugden Masterclass are nice sounding amps, but the IA-4 only gets to about 45W @ 4 Ohms.

Luxman are also worth looking at, as I'm sure you know.

I have not heard the 35i drive the SCM 19s, but if you like to play your music loud, it may not be the best choice....but should work at moderate levels. Though saying that, the 35i has more power than it has any right to, given its rating......if you can find one.  banging head against wall

__________________

"Everything has been said before, but since nobody listens we have to keep going back and beginning all over again."  André Gide

Neuphonix
Neuphonix's picture
Offline
Joined: 20 Apr 2012
Posts: 278
RE: Please advice: is 30w x2 class A enough to drive ATC SCM19?

CnoEvil wrote:

As you are probably well aware, I also own the 35i, which is the best amp under £10k that I've heard.........ideally, it likes speakers of high sensitivity (90 dB+) and low impedance, to get the most from it's doubling of power as impedance halves. This will be the case with most Class A.

The Sugden Masterclass are nice sounding amps, but the IA-4 only gets to about 45W @ 4 Ohms.

Luxman are also worth looking at, as I'm sure you know.

I have not heard the 35i drive the SCM 19s, but if you like to play your music loud, it may not be the best choice....but should work at moderate levels. Though saying that, the 35i has more power than it has any right to, given its rating......if you can find onebanging head against wall

Don't they understand that you are out on the cold face trying to push their product! This years Xmas bonus is looking a little shaky! Wink

Will be interesting to see where MF go from here. They've obviously made a decision to focus on the M series. Have you heard much about the M8 stuff?

Wonder what comes next for them in terms of high end A class? Will they do another prduction run of AMS series or realease something new.

__________________

MF AMS-Primo / MF AMS-35P / Linn Akurate DS / Focal Utopia Diablos / Krix Epicentrix / Focal Dome 2 / JL Audio Fathom F110 / JL Audio Fathom F112 / Bryston 10B-Sub / Yamaha RX-Z7 / Oppo Nuforce BDP-93 / PS3 / QNAP TS-219P Turbo NAS

CnoEvil
CnoEvil's picture
Offline
Joined: 21 Aug 2009
Posts: 8774
RE: Please advice: is 30w x2 class A enough to drive ATC SCM19?

Neuphonix wrote:

Don't they understand that you are out on the cold face trying to push their product! This years Xmas bonus is looking a little shaky! Wink

Will be interesting to see where MF go from here. They've obviously made a decision to focus on the M series. Have you heard much about the M8 stuff?

Wonder what comes next for them in terms of high end A class? Will they do another production run of AMS series or realease something new.

I was so successful selling the 35i, that they ran out!  ohhh sure

In the current recession, and with the cost of lecky, I can see the AMS series being phased out. Sad

I wouldn't be surprised to see the AMS, especially the 35i, becoming a classic.

__________________

"Everything has been said before, but since nobody listens we have to keep going back and beginning all over again."  André Gide

Neuphonix
Neuphonix's picture
Offline
Joined: 20 Apr 2012
Posts: 278
RE: Please advice: is 30w x2 class A enough to drive ATC SCM19?

CnoEvil wrote:

Neuphonix wrote:

Don't they understand that you are out on the cold face trying to push their product! This years Xmas bonus is looking a little shaky! Wink

Will be interesting to see where MF go from here. They've obviously made a decision to focus on the M series. Have you heard much about the M8 stuff?

Wonder what comes next for them in terms of high end A class? Will they do another production run of AMS series or realease something new.

I was so successful selling the 35i, that they ran out!  ohhh sure

In the current recession, and with the cost of lecky, I can see the AMS series being phased out. Sad

I wouldn't be surprised to see the AMS, especially the 35i, becoming a classic.

I suspect that you are right, whichis a real pity.

As much as i like the M series stuff I don't see it as "special". Good but not good enough toset them apart from the competition.

The smaller modular M1 range perhaps?

Have you heard anything about the M8? Not much on the net about them yet.

__________________

MF AMS-Primo / MF AMS-35P / Linn Akurate DS / Focal Utopia Diablos / Krix Epicentrix / Focal Dome 2 / JL Audio Fathom F110 / JL Audio Fathom F112 / Bryston 10B-Sub / Yamaha RX-Z7 / Oppo Nuforce BDP-93 / PS3 / QNAP TS-219P Turbo NAS

CnoEvil
CnoEvil's picture
Offline
Joined: 21 Aug 2009
Posts: 8774
RE: Please advice: is 30w x2 class A enough to drive ATC SCM19?

Neuphonix wrote:

I suspect that you are right, whichis a real pity.

As much as i like the M series stuff I don't see it as "special". Good but not good enough toset them apart from the competition.

The smaller modular M1 range perhaps?

Have you heard anything about the M8? Not much on the net about them yet.

While I rate the M6i as good, I preferred my AVR600 to it, so I'm inclined to agree.

I have seen very little about the M8.

I suspect SS will gradually move over to Class D, and Actives will become more prevalent. Unless outlawed, I see Valves continuing as a niche market, in the same way as vinyl has.

__________________

"Everything has been said before, but since nobody listens we have to keep going back and beginning all over again."  André Gide

robhifi
robhifi's picture
Offline
Joined: 8 Mar 2013
Posts: 25
RE: Please advice: is 30w x2 class A enough to drive ATC SCM19?

Thanks Cno.
I listen 99% classical and jazz in a small but dedicated room (about 140sq feet, acoustic treated with4 bass tubes and 4 diffusers ),so extreme high volume is not required.

Among Chinese audiophiles, ATC and Dynaudio are notoriously known for being " very hard to drive to full potential'.
It is commonly believed that, if the amp is not at least 3 time more expansive than the ATC/DYNA you are using, it's a waste of money, because you won't be hearing the real ATC/Dyna sound. The common amps used for ATC/Dyna speakers here are Bryston, Pass Lab,Gryphone and more recently, Bladlius. Sad to say,none British.

What do you think of that?

I have already placed order for SCM19, if I fail to drive it well with my current Accuphase power amp, would you recommend a power amp (under 4k pounds) just for 'hard to drive' speakers like ATC and Dynaudio(my next target is C1)? Please , no tube amp, and ATC amp is not available here in China.

Thanks again Smile

__________________

Speakers:Spendor SP1/2R2,Sonus Faber Minima Vintage,ATC SCM19,ELAC 203.2, Monitor Audio S2

Amps:Accuphase C-2420, Accuphase A-35,Rotel 1062,NAD 355BEE,Onkyo tx809

Sources:Marantz SA11-S2 , ROTEL 1072,OPPO 93

Projector: Sanyo z2000

Subs: M&K Sub12,Elac 101.2

Room:4.5mx3m with diffusersX4 and bass tubesX4,dedicated

Exoticsounds
Exoticsounds's picture
Offline
Joined: 1 Jan 2013
Posts: 59
RE: Please advice: is 30w x2 class A enough to drive ATC SCM19?

ATC-SCM19 have a sensitivety of 85db, so would need some heavy duty power to play loud.

But aslong as you dont need to "rock" the house, your current amp should be able to drive them just fine.

From Accuphase's own description of  A35:

The power supply of an amplifier is its ultimate source of energy. Unless it provides ample reserves, sound quality will suffer, and even basic performance parameters may not be met. The A-35 has a massive power transformer and two 47,000 μF smoothing capacitors specially selected for their sonic properties. This sustains an output power rating of 120 watts into 2 ohms, 60 watts into 4 ohms, or 30 watts into 8 ohms per channel, and it enables the A-35 to perfectly handle even very-low impedance speakers or speakers with wildly fluctuating impedance characteristics.

CnoEvil
CnoEvil's picture
Offline
Joined: 21 Aug 2009
Posts: 8774
RE: Please advice: is 30w x2 class A enough to drive ATC SCM19?

robhifi wrote:
Thanks Cno. I listen 99% classical and jazz in a small but dedicated room (about 140sq feet, acoustic treated with4 bass tubes and 4 diffusers ),so extreme high volume is not required. Among Chinese audiophiles, ATC and Dynaudio are notoriously known for being " very hard to drive to full potential'. It is commonly believed that, if the amp is not at least 3 time more expansive than the ATC/DYNA you are using, it's a waste of money, because you won't be hearing the real ATC/Dyna sound. The common amps used for ATC/Dyna speakers here are Bryston, Pass Lab,Gryphone and more recently, Bladlius. Sad to say,none British. What do you think of that? I have already placed order for SCM19, if I fail to drive it well with my current Accuphase power amp, would you recommend a power amp (under 4k pounds) just for 'hard to drive' speakers like ATC and Dynaudio(my next target is C1)? Please , no tube amp, and ATC amp is not available here in China. Thanks again Smile

There is a good chance that you will get away with your A-35, which seems to behave very like my MF....and may be hard to beat without spending a fortune.

FWIW. Power amps that I would recommend are (but may be much too expensive for driving the SCM19s):

Sugden MPA-4 Monos

Electrocompaniet AW180

Audio Analogue Class SE Power

Plinius SA-103

Classe CA2300

Musical Fidelity AMS 50

I have heard Bladelius, which sounds well. Bryston will give a very clean, powerful and neutral sound; and Pass Lab has a tremendous reputation.

Let us know how you go, and hopefully you will be fine without changing your beautiful amp.

Cno

__________________

"Everything has been said before, but since nobody listens we have to keep going back and beginning all over again."  André Gide

MajorFubar
MajorFubar's picture
Offline
Joined: 3 Mar 2010
Posts: 2347
RE: Please advice: is 30w x2 class A enough to drive ATC SCM19?

There's a lot of misunderstanding about Watts and amps. A 30 Watt amp will go loud enough to make your ears bleed in an average room and with average speakers.  It's not Wattage that's important it's clean current delivery.

__________________

Main gear: Mac Mini > HRT Streamer II+ > Marantz PM66 KI > Mission 794

Also cluttering-up the place:

Thorens TD160 no cartridge; Marantz CD63 mkII KI; Technics SL-P777; Cyrus 2 + PSX; Cyrus Tuner; Nakamichi DR-1

fr0g
fr0g's picture
Offline
Joined: 7 Jan 2008
Posts: 2126
RE: Please advice: is 30w x2 class A enough to drive ATC SCM19?
__________________

“Out beyond ideas of wrong and  right, there is a field.

I'll meet you there."

 

 

Neuphonix
Neuphonix's picture
Offline
Joined: 20 Apr 2012
Posts: 278
RE: Please advice: is 30w x2 class A enough to drive ATC SCM19?

Just been having another look at the specs on the smc19. One question, how much more bass do you think you'll be getting? i mean sure its going to be an improvement over your current scm7 but they are only spec to go down to 54Hz.

Maybe the Dynaudio Confidence C1 would have been worth holding out for. What is the price difference?

I really cant see your amp having any dramas.

__________________

MF AMS-Primo / MF AMS-35P / Linn Akurate DS / Focal Utopia Diablos / Krix Epicentrix / Focal Dome 2 / JL Audio Fathom F110 / JL Audio Fathom F112 / Bryston 10B-Sub / Yamaha RX-Z7 / Oppo Nuforce BDP-93 / PS3 / QNAP TS-219P Turbo NAS

Craig M.
Craig M.'s picture
Offline
Joined: 20 Mar 2008
Posts: 2728
RE: Please advice: is 30w x2 class A enough to drive ATC SCM19?

MajorFubar wrote:

There's a lot of misunderstanding about Watts and amps. A 30 Watt amp will go loud enough to make your ears bleed in an average room and with average speakers.  It's not Wattage that's important it's clean current delivery.

I'd agree with this ONLY if the 30w amp has a lot of dynamic headroom.  If 30w is all it can put out full stop, then it's not nearly enough for a lot of speakers at an average listening distance - unless you actually want lots of clipped peaks and damaged speakers.  Remember, clean undistorted volume doesn't actually seem that loud - distortion seems loud.  A clipping amp sounds loud.  Read the Distortion segment of THIS.

A good example of a dynamic 'low powered' amp would be Cno's, it can put out waaay more than 35w for short bursts. 

From memory, the SCM19s have a fairly flat impedance curve that only dips to around 5 ohms so don't need loads of current, but they are inefficient so lots of dynamic headroom will be needed if you want to make the most of their excellent dynamics.

THIS article explains it well.

__________________

Synology NAS + Audio Station - ATV2 - Benchmark DAC1 HDR - Event Opal

 

http://nwavguy.blogspot.co.uk/2012/04/what-we-hear.html

CnoEvil
CnoEvil's picture
Offline
Joined: 21 Aug 2009
Posts: 8774
RE: Please advice: is 30w x2 class A enough to drive ATC SCM19?

Craig M. wrote:

MajorFubar wrote:

There's a lot of misunderstanding about Watts and amps. A 30 Watt amp will go loud enough to make your ears bleed in an average room and with average speakers.  It's not Wattage that's important it's clean current delivery.

I'd agree with this ONLY if the 30w amp has a lot of dynamic headroom.  If 30w is all it can put out full stop, then it's not nearly enough for a lot of speakers at an average listening distance - unless you actually want lots of clipped peaks and damaged speakers.  Remember, clean undistorted volume doesn't actually seem that loud - distortion seems loud.  A clipping amp sounds loud.  Read the Distortion segment of THIS.

A good example of a dynamic 'low powered' amp would be Cno's, it can put out waaay more than 35w for short bursts. 

From memory, the SCM19s have a fairly flat impedance curve that only dips to around 5 ohms so don't need loads of current, but they are inefficient so lots of dynamic headroom will be needed if you want to make the most of their excellent dynamics.

THIS article explains it well.

My speakers have a Sensitivity of 90dB, as opposed to the 85dB of the SCM19s, which makes quite a difference where only 30-35W are on offer. The Refs also drop down to 3.2 Ohms, which again plays to the strength of an amp that has high current delivery...compared to the benign impedance (5 Ohms) of the ATC.

So I agree with all the comments on this thread, with the very slight caveat, that the SCM19s may ideally be more suited to to an amp with more Watts, if loudish volumes in a largish room are involved......@ OP - What is your ceiling height?

I still think the OP will be all right, but am cautious by nature....especially when giving advice.

__________________

"Everything has been said before, but since nobody listens we have to keep going back and beginning all over again."  André Gide