Have your say & ask the experts!

Marantz Gear

12 replies [Last post]
strobo
strobo's picture
Offline
Joined: 6 Sep 2007
Posts: 117

Seems odd that Marantz and Denon (partner companies), seem to have exchanged the mantels of making great vs average hi-fi and home cinema, doesn't it? Hmmm, not that I'm a cynic when it comes to marketing tactics or anything... Anyway, I'm curious how the reviewers rate the stereo CD output of the £300 Marantz DV6001 in the latest issue against the two current standalone players, the £170 CD5001 (including the CD5001 OSE if anybody has heard one), and the £270 CD 6002. (I've included the RRP's as much for my benefit when I come back to this post as for anything else). Whaddya think?

Clare Newsome
Clare Newsome's picture
Offline
Joined: 4 Jun 2007
Posts: 13733
Re: Marantz Gear

 The Marantz DV6001 offers good CD replay for a DVD player, but the CD6002 murders it in stereo. Then again, the latter isn't much good playing movies....

Using one player to do music and movies always involves an element of compromise, sadly - all we can do is point you in the direction of the least-compromised AV kit in terms of stereo, should you want to have a do-it-all machine. 

__________________

Group PR Manager - Computers Unlimited;

Former Group Editor of What Hi-Fi? Sound and Vision and Whathifi.com

Twitter: @ClareNewsome

strobo
strobo's picture
Offline
Joined: 6 Sep 2007
Posts: 117
Re: Marantz Gear

I hardly had time to make a cup of tea before you replied Clare - soooper fast!!!

Muchos tagliatelli, as I think the Italians say.

I'm kinda stumped about which route to go down. Basically I need a CD player for the home cinema setup (the old Pioneer DVD player is very limited in this role). The front speakers are to be replaced with Tannoy's Mercury F1's (my old M1's are doing sterling work at the mo, sounding pretty darned good - considering the less than ideal location and the rear ports). I bought a Toshiba SD370 the other week and am impressed with that, so a new DVD isn't essential, but the Toshiba could easily be re-homed in the bedroom. I just can't decide whether to upgrade the CD and DVD in one fell swoop with a combined unit (and added domestic harmony), or keep the Toshiba downstairs, and just buy a CD player.

I suppose buying the combined unit, I could always buy a standalone CD player later anyway... Hmmm.

silly
silly's picture
Offline
Joined: 31 Aug 2007
Posts: 459
Re: Marantz Gear

I find Marantz CD players,good,but very over rated,especially the CD63SE all those yours ago.The CD5001 to me was a poor player,thin,bright and harsh.But if you want the best of both worlds,I would get a DVD player and add a high quality DAC.

strobo
strobo's picture
Offline
Joined: 6 Sep 2007
Posts: 117
Re: Marantz Gear

I always like Marantz gear. I think it always complemented more Marantz gear best though, and not always anything else.

Thaiman
Thaiman's picture
Offline
Joined: 28 Jul 2007
Posts: 4228
Re: Marantz Gear

user="strobo" wrote:
Whaddya think?

I think you have a longest signature I have ever seen in any forums and your bedroom system sound better than your main one!

__________________

 

TW Raven AC - Soundsmith SG-410 - MSB 202 - Gershman Acoustics Black Swan - Audioquest K9

 

strobo
strobo's picture
Offline
Joined: 6 Sep 2007
Posts: 117
Re: Marantz Gear

I think you're right on both counts mate.

The bedroom system was bought ten years ago, but on a bit of a whim. I was about to lose my job so blew my last full pay packet on my first proper hi-fi gear. Best pay packet I ever blew. I always intended to upgrade to things like the CD63KI etc, but the money and the inclination were never really there.

The main system is slowly replacing existing stuff which I had little say in the purchase of. Now I've got my grubby little mitts on the living room sound system I'm making the most of it. But as most of the essential bits are already there, there's no point rushing into things.

The Denon receiver has been a revelation though. It really is a massive leap forward from my old PM-57 amp (not exactly hi spec even ten years ago, but very nice all the same). I'm not sure I'll find such a leap forwards from a new CD player though. But time will tell.

Thaiman
Thaiman's picture
Offline
Joined: 28 Jul 2007
Posts: 4228
Re: Marantz Gear

user="strobo" wrote:
I always intended to upgrade to things like the CD63KI etc,
 

 I still think Marantz 63 ose KI still one of the best bargain in Hifi world today, if I have to sell my system and got only £500 to spend on replacement they would be the 1st item I would buy (£150-ish for a good condition one).  I still own a marantz CD17 Ki which I moded myself and sometime I think it's not that much better than the 63 KI!

__________________

 

TW Raven AC - Soundsmith SG-410 - MSB 202 - Gershman Acoustics Black Swan - Audioquest K9

 

strobo
strobo's picture
Offline
Joined: 6 Sep 2007
Posts: 117
Re: Marantz Gear

I think I remember the CD17KI. Was that the one available in black or champagne (that slightly golden silvery colour)? As I remember they made a matching amp with a meter in the middle and nothing else on the fascia. The meter had a little blue LED didn't it? On looks alone I thought that was the CD/amp combo to end all combo's.

Thaiman
Thaiman's picture
Offline
Joined: 28 Jul 2007
Posts: 4228
Re: Marantz Gear

That's the one! lush and smooth, doesn't suite all taste but great for main steam brit pop and 70's rock, highly recommended.

__________________

 

TW Raven AC - Soundsmith SG-410 - MSB 202 - Gershman Acoustics Black Swan - Audioquest K9

 

jetjohnson
jetjohnson's picture
Offline
Joined: 11 Aug 2007
Posts: 165
Re: Marantz Gear

As far as CD players are concerned I'm definitely a Marantz fan ....apart from an early Technics I've had various Marantz players for about 20 years. As far as one-box players go I see no reason to buy any other make (and their new affordable player seems a good un' according to WH)

My own favourite was the CD 85 SE a wonderfully built player which I bought whilst still firmly committed to vinyl simply because it's bass control was the nearest thing I'd heard to compete with a high end turntable.  if you can get hold of a used one in good nick on ebay I'd go for it even now.

I've heard some of the other cheaper Marantz's and enjoyed them as well ...although there is a "Marantz sound" that may not be to everyone's taste.   

__________________

Oracle Delphi 1 / Zeta /Goldring 2200. Onkyo Tr 875. Marantz CD 85 SE.Sony CDX 355 300 Disc CD Multi-Player

Lake Audio 1015 Ft Speakers and Lake Audio Ctr. Wharfdale Diamond III Rears. Ruark Vita 100 Sub Woofer. Pioneer PX 50d Plasma. Denon 1940 DVD. Panasonic DMR ex 777 HD/DVD-R.  Pioneer 989 avi DVD Player.  Sony BDP185 Blu Ray player, Sky HD Box

 

Thaiman
Thaiman's picture
Offline
Joined: 28 Jul 2007
Posts: 4228
Re: Marantz Gear

If anyone want a decent cdp for £50 - £70 I always recomended Marantz 67 MK2.  Plenty around 2nd hand so walk away from a tatty example, original box add £5 to the value and remote control can be find easily for less than tenner.  Match it with PM66 OSE and a pair of B&W601....bingo! a very good hifi system for £250.

__________________

 

TW Raven AC - Soundsmith SG-410 - MSB 202 - Gershman Acoustics Black Swan - Audioquest K9

 

tlafp
tlafp's picture
Offline
Joined: 23 Sep 2007
Posts: 5
Re: Marantz Gear

Hi all!

 

jetjohnson, what do you mean by a ""Marantz sound" that may not be to everyone's taste ?". How would you characterize the "Marantz" sound ?

 

My CD player is a Technics SL-PS670D, from around ten years ago (the same age as the rest of the components). Since you've had a Technics yourself, do you think I will like the transition to the new Marantz CD6002 ?

 
The rest of the kit is comprised of a NAD 312 amp and original B&W DM602 speakers.

 

Thanks!
 

 

user="jetjohnson" wrote:

As far as CD players are concerned I'm definitely a Marantz fan ....apart from an early Technics I've had various Marantz players for about 20 years. As far as one-box players go I see no reason to buy any other make (and their new affordable player seems a good un' according to WH)

My own favourite was the CD 85 SE a wonderfully built player which I bought whilst still firmly committed to vinyl simply because it's bass control was the nearest thing I'd heard to compete with a high end turntable.  if you can get hold of a used one in good nick on ebay I'd go for it even now.

I've heard some of the other cheaper Marantz's and enjoyed them as well ...although there is a "Marantz sound" that may not be to everyone's taste.