Have your say & ask the experts!

As the Nait 5i, but more detailed

29 replies [Last post]
Goethe
Goethe's picture
Offline
Joined: 27 Jan 2011
Posts: 77

Hi all.

Recently I got a Naim Nait 5i, which is connected to an Audiolab 8200cd and some EB Acoustic EB2. The combination is fantastic because Naim has eliminated the rough, wheezing and brightness that I had with other amps. And now the music is full of life, rhythm and momentum. I love the sound of Naim! The problem is that the Audiolab and EB2 are very detailed, but the Naim eliminates most of these details, which are one of the reasons why I bought this player and these speakers.

Does anyone know if there is an amplifier with the sound of the Nait 5i (warm, punchy, rithmic) but more detailed and transparent? I do not want to ruin:my budget is around 1000 pounds.

Thank you!

plastic penguin
plastic penguin's picture
Offline
Joined: 28 Apr 2008
Posts: 13201
RE: As the Nait 5i, but more detailed

Good question TBH. This could be a case of too much detail could kill the overall presentation. From what I've heard about the EBs and a very short listening with the Audiolab CDP, yes they are very detailed. The issue comes when you start adding to the detail side: Sometimes additional detail can make it sound brittle, hence why mix 'n' matching is vitally important you strike the right balance.

If you like the combo but hanker after more detail it maybe worth holding back a while. Changing the amp may change the overall feel and you'll lose the lovely sound currently.

What cables do you use with your set-up?

 

Edit - The obvious choice for an amp is the Naim XS. I personally think it has all the traits you're looking for, and it's on par with my Leema Pulse. Alternatively, look at Roksan Kandy K2 and Creek Evo2.

__________________

Leema Pulse MKII-S; Naim CD5i MKII; Denon TU-260L MKII; MA RS6 speakers; Pro-ject Xpression 1; loads of different cables...

 

Formerly known as plastic penguin

nightrhyme
nightrhyme's picture
Offline
Joined: 8 Mar 2009
Posts: 19
RE: As the Nait 5i, but more detailed

Hate to ruin your budget. But the answer is an easy one: Naim XS

Goethe
Goethe's picture
Offline
Joined: 27 Jan 2011
Posts: 77
RE: As the Nait 5i, but more detailed

nightrhyme wrote:

Hate to ruin your budget. But the answer is an easy one: Naim XS

 

I suspected it. How detailed is the XS? Not as much as the Cyrus 8xp, according to the review of WHF, but more than a Marantz?

 

Thanks!

Goethe
Goethe's picture
Offline
Joined: 27 Jan 2011
Posts: 77
RE: As the Nait 5i, but more detailed

plastic penguin wrote:

Good question TBH. This could be a case of too much detail could kill the overall presentation. From what I've heard about the EBs and a very short listening with the Audiolab CDP, yes they are very detailed. The issue comes when you start adding to the detail side: Sometimes additional detail can make it sound brittle, hence why mix 'n' matching is vitally important you strike the right balance.

If you like the combo but hanker after more detail it maybe worth holding back a while. Changing the amp may change the overall feel and you'll lose the lovely sound currently.

What cables do you use with your set-up?

 

Edit - The obvious choice for an amp is the Naim XS. I personally think it has all the traits you're looking for, and it's on par with my Leema Pulse. Alternatively, look at Roksan Kandy K2 and Creek Evo2.

 

Thanks for your advice. I use chord cables, but I do not think they affect much in the detail.

 

You are right: with Cyrus the combo was very detailed, but wheezing and too bright for me. She caused me a headache!

 

Do you think than Roksan, Creek and Leema have the same sound funny, warm and punchy than Naim?

 

Thanks!

plastic penguin
plastic penguin's picture
Offline
Joined: 28 Apr 2008
Posts: 13201
RE: As the Nait 5i, but more detailed

Goethe wrote:

plastic penguin wrote:

Good question TBH. This could be a case of too much detail could kill the overall presentation. From what I've heard about the EBs and a very short listening with the Audiolab CDP, yes they are very detailed. The issue comes when you start adding to the detail side: Sometimes additional detail can make it sound brittle, hence why mix 'n' matching is vitally important you strike the right balance.

If you like the combo but hanker after more detail it maybe worth holding back a while. Changing the amp may change the overall feel and you'll lose the lovely sound currently.

What cables do you use with your set-up?

 

Edit - The obvious choice for an amp is the Naim XS. I personally think it has all the traits you're looking for, and it's on par with my Leema Pulse. Alternatively, look at Roksan Kandy K2 and Creek Evo2.

 

Thanks for your advice. I use chord cables, but I do not think they affect much in the detail.

 

You are right: with Cyrus the combo was very detailed, but wheezing and too bright for me. She caused me a headache!

 

Do you think than Roksan, Creek and Leema have the same sound funny, warm and punchy than Naim?

 

Thanks!

The Kandy and Creek won't out punch the Nait 5i but the Leema will. The Kandy and the Creek have a nice full-bodied or warmish presentation, and will outgun the Nait (not by much) in detail, although it'll be more subtle. The Pulse, on the other hand, is the best integrated amp I've heard below the 2k mark... and it has incredible punch. Don't mistake that with bass depth. It has deep, taut bass and in isolation nothing else will do. It's only when you hear the Caspian or XS side-by-side with the Leema that the Welsh beauty ever-so-slightly lacks. Overall, though, the Leema improves on the Nait 5i in pretty much every area. Albeit very noticable it isn't 'night and day'. Although not warm the Leema does have a lovely organic tonal balance.

__________________

Leema Pulse MKII-S; Naim CD5i MKII; Denon TU-260L MKII; MA RS6 speakers; Pro-ject Xpression 1; loads of different cables...

 

Formerly known as plastic penguin

Goethe
Goethe's picture
Offline
Joined: 27 Jan 2011
Posts: 77
RE: As the Nait 5i, but more detailed

Thanks for your reply. My concern is that the final sound, combined with the 8200cd and the EB2, can not be too hurtful at high frequencies.

plastic penguin
plastic penguin's picture
Offline
Joined: 28 Apr 2008
Posts: 13201
RE: As the Nait 5i, but more detailed

Goethe wrote:

Thanks for your reply. My concern is that the final sound, combined with the 8200cd and the EB2, can not be too hurtful at high frequencies.

Well, the Leema has wonderful control over my RS6s treble, which can become slightly shrill with the wrong amp. When I heard the Leema/Audiolab 8200 and RS6s at a dealers last year, it sounded 'alive' but... the problem I have is I like a slightly laid back presentation, hence why my sources tend to have these traits.

Could also look at cables. There are a few on here who are really impressed by Tellurium Q black, describing it as far more detailed than most other cables. However, it comes at a price: About £40 per metre. Or alternatively, look at the TQ Blue, which are cheaper.

I'm currently using Chord SilverScreen speaker cable and Merlin Chopin interconnects (CD to amp), and the Merlins are open and transparent. Fabulous for a sub £100 i/c.

__________________

Leema Pulse MKII-S; Naim CD5i MKII; Denon TU-260L MKII; MA RS6 speakers; Pro-ject Xpression 1; loads of different cables...

 

Formerly known as plastic penguin

rich51080
rich51080's picture
Offline
Joined: 24 Jul 2007
Posts: 177
RE: As the Nait 5i, but more detailed

Exposure 3010 would be well worth a try. lots of PRaT and also detailed.

IMO a little step up from the Nait and more on par with the XS range.

oldric_naubhoff
oldric_naubhoff's picture
Offline
Joined: 12 Mar 2011
Posts: 1032
RE: As the Nait 5i, but more detailed

you could also check out my amp; Classic One mkIII, entry level form Pathos.

never heard your CDP nor your speakers. however, my set up sound like something you described you want to get; detailed and fast but fluid, musical and non fatiguing.

mind you, what you're trying to get is probably the most difficult thing to get in hi-fi, at least at budget level; the high level of musical detail true hi-fi is capable of achieving but no associated head ache Smile. good luck on your endeavour.

__________________

Giro, InTheGroove, Digit, ClassicOne, MG12

Goethe
Goethe's picture
Offline
Joined: 27 Jan 2011
Posts: 77
RE: As the Nait 5i, but more detailed

Yes, I think I I'm looking for the Holy Grail of sound: warm, very detailed, with PRAT and without fatigue. Laughing

 

The problem is that these speakers are not in stores, and it is impossible to hear the final result before buying. Cry

 

For now, I will take de Naim sound. Later, If I find one of the these amplifiers (Leema, XS, Roksan, Exposure) a good price, I will venture.

plastic penguin
plastic penguin's picture
Offline
Joined: 28 Apr 2008
Posts: 13201
RE: As the Nait 5i, but more detailed

Wise decision to stay with a combo you like, even if it isn't utopia. The old saying, "if it ain't broke..." rings so true with hi-fi.

__________________

Leema Pulse MKII-S; Naim CD5i MKII; Denon TU-260L MKII; MA RS6 speakers; Pro-ject Xpression 1; loads of different cables...

 

Formerly known as plastic penguin

oldric_naubhoff
oldric_naubhoff's picture
Offline
Joined: 12 Mar 2011
Posts: 1032
RE: As the Nait 5i, but more detailed

Goethe wrote:

The problem is that these speakers are not in stores, and it is impossible to hear the final result before buying. Cry

Smile I was only saying that you could try out my amp if you get a chance, not the whole set up.

but you're right. Focus110s are now discontinued. but I'm using Magnepan MG12s ATM. and I think they are vasly superior speakers. since when Maggies arrived (beginning of Jan) I haven't changed them for Dyns. I think it's about time for me to change the bio.... Smile

__________________

Giro, InTheGroove, Digit, ClassicOne, MG12

Gazzip
Gazzip's picture
Offline
Joined: 15 Jan 2011
Posts: 126
RE: As the Nait 5i, but more detailed

Spoken from disappointed experience, nothing from Cyrus that I have owned worked with the EB 2's.
This was echoed by EB Acoustics who were "left feeling cold" by their experience of the EB/Cyrus combo.

8VS2
X Power
Mono X's

None of the above worked and all sounded very bright and lightweight.
Steer clear of that combo. (although I haven't tried my current weapon of choice, Mono X300's).

__________________

Main System: Bryston BP26DA Pre Amp & DAC; Bryston 4B SST2 Power Amp; PMC PB1i Signatures; Squeezebox Touch; Chord Company Signature and Anthem 2 cables

 

Second System: Cyrus 2 and PSX; Spendor S3e's; Squeezebox Touch; Chord Company Odyssey and Crimson cables

Potts
Potts's picture
Offline
Joined: 31 Mar 2011
Posts: 36
RE: As the Nait 5i, but more detailed

Similar to the above posts, and might be a tad biased... but I'd recommend the Nait XS highly. It seems to have everything that you're looking for, however I don't know how it compares to the other amps that the guys on here have suggested.

I started with the Nait 5i and upgraded to the XS, it just seemed like a natural progression as I enjoyed the sound of the Nait 5i so much.

__________________

PC / ASIO -> Chord USB SilverPlus -> Rega DAC -> Chord Chameleon Interconnect -> Naim Nait XS / Flat Cap XS -> Chord Epic Speaker Cable / Chord Signature Links -> B&W 683

Audio Maniac
Audio Maniac's picture
Offline
Joined: 25 Apr 2011
Posts: 228
RE: As the Nait 5i, but more detailed

If you are after a warmth without detail loss I recommend Accuphase E-250 and Luxman L-505u. They are expensive but they worth every penny and are far better than Naim XS. The L-505u is punchier and cheaper.