Have your say & ask the experts!

Who's best Xbox or Playstation....

30 replies [Last post]
AVstu's picture
Offline
Joined: 7 Jul 2008
Posts: 30

Hi all

Just had to get that in first .....)))))))))))))))))

Alantiggger's picture
Offline
Joined: 14 Oct 2007
Posts: 1584
RE: Gaming

What is better ?

It will have a good few disagreeing but my son and all of his friends seem to play the xbox 360 ... is it better ? I have no idea but I do know that a pc is better for gaming than both   Smile

__________________

Lounge :  Samsung PS51E6500, Sony BDP S790, Virgin media XL with HD Sports Channels (BT &Sky),  Yamaha RX-V673.

Tannoy Arena 5.1 with stands.(http://www.techradar.com/reviews/audio-visual/hi-fi-and-audio/hi-fi-and-av-speakers/tannoy-arena-96472/review)

Bedroom: Panasonic PX70 TV and a Sony BDP-370 Blu ray Player & Kitsound Boomdock.  (quite superb for sound)

So far  :)

 

smuggs's picture
Offline
Joined: 19 Feb 2009
Posts: 1074
RE: Gaming

-online,  if ind the xbox puts me with english people most the time where ps3 i find i play french,germans ect alot,the ps3 always seems to be bit laggy and option has problems through the year 2010 i can remember aleast 5 nights my friend could not go online.. i also find there is alot of swearing on the ps3 and silly mum jokes that may me that the people have not paid the a fee to go online and are often younger on ps3. i have to say though that the xbox seems harder as if all are gaming geeks.So i sometimes find it abit off putting.

i find the ps3 better build, offline play better less fan nosie(i have the black elite though not the new xbox)and with a blu ray player and more internet options (iplayers)i would say the ps3 is a better all rounder. but if online gaming is a must then xbox is far better.

__________________

Samsung 46 led tv-yamaha 673 -skyhd-wd tv live streaming;-wd my book 2tb nas-apple tv3-xbox360-aria gaming pc -genie2(2mred)-Montior Audio Br5's Br-LCR Br1's Brw10 sub-ipad(2g)-samsung gs2-akg 450

Cookie Monster's picture
Offline
Joined: 25 Jan 2010
Posts: 379
RE: Gaming

I had an original 20GB Xbox and it didn't get RROD. Yet i am on my 4th PS3 in 4 years!

The fan noise persuaded me to sell my Xbox and the extra £50 per year for Live. Also i couldn't get voice chat to work and all i could hear were racist,swearing very young americans. The best console for me was the original Xbox and its excellent introduction to online gaming and a great mature friends list.

Still the BD playback and the opportunity to play Wipeout HD drove me back to Sony. Free online gaming was the icing on a good value cake. Shame i can't speak so highly of Sony/PS3 customer service and their YLOD denial.

Xbox looks great at the moment and at the right price i may consider another.

Personally think its about games not hardware. I still own an old Sega Saturn for its old arcade conversions and a great version of 'Space Harrier'. Wish i had kept my SNES though.

 

__________________

Philips 42PFL7404,Epson EH-TW5900 PJ, 77" Euroscreen, Yamaha YSP-2200, SKY HD, Sony BDP-S370, PS3, Tacima Mains Conditioner, Wireworld, QED, Thatcable HDMI's. Handmade Mains Cable, Sharkoon DD5.1 Headphones - Staffordshire 

Mr. Iceman's picture
Offline
Joined: 29 Nov 2008
Posts: 155
RE: Gaming

My son and I share 2 PS3s (mine is the slim version but he prefers the fat one as it is compatible with PS2 games), PS2, new XBox, Wii, latest PSP, Nintendo DSi, several laptops, iPod Touch etc., all used for everyday gaming. Not all of them every day of course. I also had several PS Ones. As enjoyable as all of them are (and for different reasons) my favourite has been PS3 for the same reasons that smuggs mentioned earlier. I would like to add to the list its excellent menu system and streaming abilities - it makes one great media hub. I still have a working 20-y/o SNES with some 50-odd game cartridges - funny how technology has changed but most of the games for the olde console are as enjoyable and frustrating as ever. Even more frustrating to complete than many games I played on most recent consoles. It probably has to do with poor controls and lack of ad-hoc saving points in old games and consoles (and relatively poor graphics/sound as well...). So PS3 wins it for me, and by some margin - if only the Forza racer franchise was available for it, I never would have bought the XBox...

f1only's picture
Offline
Joined: 7 Apr 2010
Posts: 1059
RE: Gaming Ps3 Vs Xbox 360

IMO neither are best, they are both flawed.

Ps3 i'm just about to send my 4th 60gb Phat one back for another BD drive failure ( i dont play on it more than a couple of hours a week ), deep joy for reliability as ive not had it for a year yet, good job I have a spare slim 320gb ( seems more reliable so far, I havn't had it for a year yet either) & Continual Play Insurance.

 Worse than the Ps2 ( 4 In total failed, last one lasted over 3 years ) & the Ps1 ( 3 In total with 2 failing ). I have a large area around my ps3 too for ventilation, well over 6 inches all around the console, well over a foot of free air above, plus it is kept as clean & as dust free as is reasonably possible.

My nephew has had 3 Xbox 360's two failed in less than a year, in the end he part exchanged the last one & bought a ps3 slim. My step son is about to sell his 3rd Xbox 360 a 120gb Elite model for similar reasons.

The old cartridge machines faired better IMO except for the Atari 2600 ( oops .. showing my age here, good job i didn't mention Pong Laughing ). I never had any problems with the old Sega Master System, Megadrive &  the Nintendo Snes.

I think the the main problem with the 2 consoles is, they just were not tested for a long enough period of time before being released to the general public. The only reason i bought the Ps3 was because as my handle suggests i love the F1 games & the Xbox did not have any at the time of my purchase.

Even because of all this aggrevation i have had with consoles from Sony, i certainly wouldn't recommend them. I would though, still buy one on the grounds that it is deffinately a more versatile machine, that has a lot going for it.

 My advice, take out some kind of extra warranty on which ever machine you decide to buy if you are reading this & trying to decide on which to purchase. 

__________________

TV: Sony KDL-46HX853 ( calibrated ), Virgin Tivo Box, BD Players: Sony BDP-S790,  PS3, PS4 & Panasonic DMR-BWT700

A/V Amp: Yamaha RX-V1073

Speakers: Dali Ikon 6 Front L/R, Dali Ikon 1's Surround, Dali Ikon Vocal 2 Centre, B&W ASW610 Subwoofer.

My System

Sony Bravia 46HX853 Calibrated Settings

sonycentre's picture
Offline
Joined: 30 May 2009
Posts: 637
RE: Gaming

Both console's have there good and bad point's,audio wise the ps3 sounds loads better then the x-box as the ps3 can do dts and pcm sound.If you need to hear it then wipeout hd is in 7.1 pcm sound(it sounds awesome) uncharted 1 and 2 both have hd audio upto 7.1.The xbox meanwhile(i have had the arcade,elite and now the new shiny 250gig versions) and online play is better for me on x-box.And i prefer the controller on x-box.But on a tech level ps3 is way ahead.

__________________

Running a pub.....bring on the entertainment!!!!!

margetti's picture
Online
Joined: 29 May 2008
Posts: 1021
RE: Gaming Ps3 Vs Xbox 360

As said, each has their pro's and con's, but as much as I've tried to give the PS a fair chance, I just prefer gaming on the xbox. I don't know if it's as simple as the fact I prefer the xbox controller, but I just don't get on as well with the PS3.

What I do find frustrating with the PS3 - although this is probably as much to do with the fact that it isn't in constant use, is that everytime I do use it it seems to want to spend half an hour doing multiple updates.

I did however discover a hybrid SACD disc in my collection over the weekend, and must say it did sound superb on the PS3 - Sony sure did pack in a lot of wonderful extras, esp. the original PS3.

And finally, at the risk of tempting fate, I must be extremely lucky with the hardware - only one failure (the dreaded RROD on the xbox) which was covered by Microsoft's extended warranty and was returned fixed within a couple of weeks.

__________________

Hi-fi: Sonneteer amp, cdp & phono amp, Systemdek IIx900, Rasp Pi + HiFiBerry DAC, ProAc Response D Two speakers

AV: Onkyo 876, Ruark speakers, REL Strata 5, Panasonic 50GT60

"People who think they know everything are a great annoyance to those of us who do" - Isaac Asimov

Paul.'s picture
Offline
Joined: 26 Nov 2010
Posts: 2844
RE: Gaming

This thread is worrying me... I have the original 60gb fat with all the trimmings, four USB slots, ability to play PS2 games etc.  My GF won it at work and gave it to me for my birthday when the PS3 had only just been released.  Miraculously, I am still on my first one!

__________________

Paul's system thread

(where the photos live) Paul's Flickr page

professorhat's picture
Offline
Joined: 28 Dec 2007
Posts: 11011
RE: Gaming

Paul Hobbs wrote:

This thread is worrying me... I have the original 60gb fat with all the trimmings, four USB slots, ability to play PS2 games etc.  My GF won it at work and gave it to me for my birthday when the PS3 had only just been released.  Miraculously, I am still on my first one!

Me too - bought on day of release and still going strong. Xbox has been replaced once due to RROD.

 

aliEnRIK's picture
Offline
Joined: 27 Aug 2008
Posts: 3695
RE: Gaming Ps3 Vs Xbox 360

f1only wrote:

IMO neither are best, they are both flawed.

Ps3 i'm just about to send my 4th 60gb Phat one back for another BD drive failure ( i dont play on it more than a couple of hours a week ), deep joy for reliability as ive not had it for a year yet, good job I have a spare slim 320gb ( seems more reliable so far, I havn't had it for a year yet either) & Continual Play Insurance.

 Worse than the Ps2 ( 4 In total failed, last one lasted over 3 years ) & the Ps1 ( 3 In total with 2 failing ). I have a large area around my ps3 too for ventilation, well over 6 inches all around the console, well over a foot of free air above, plus it is kept as clean & as dust free as is reasonably possible.

 

I have the original fat PS3, still have my original PS2 and my PS1 was working right up till I sold it - no issues with any of them

One thing I will say about the PS3 - mines on rubber feet that ive added. I have noticed it gets pretty hot 'under' the PS3 without them so I suspect many PS3s would have failed because of that

__________________

Marantz AV8003 Pre Amp. Musical Fidelity A5 Power Amp. Arcam P1000 Power Amp. Monitor Audio Silver 8i and surrounds. Oppo 95. Sony 46W5500. PS3. 16 core braided mains cables. Atlas Titan and Ascent cables. Isotek Sigmas. Balanced mains transformer.

f1only's picture
Offline
Joined: 7 Apr 2010
Posts: 1059
RE: Gaming Ps3 Vs Xbox 360

Sounds good to me RIK, I'll give that a try when the replacement arrives.

Up untill recently I have had a fan on slow, blowing cool air over mine & then changed to one that plugs in to the USB ports, it seems without much success, so i dont bother now.

 I have just come off the phone to Sony & DPD are doing a swap for another Thursday sometime.

__________________

TV: Sony KDL-46HX853 ( calibrated ), Virgin Tivo Box, BD Players: Sony BDP-S790,  PS3, PS4 & Panasonic DMR-BWT700

A/V Amp: Yamaha RX-V1073

Speakers: Dali Ikon 6 Front L/R, Dali Ikon 1's Surround, Dali Ikon Vocal 2 Centre, B&W ASW610 Subwoofer.

My System

Sony Bravia 46HX853 Calibrated Settings

smuggs's picture
Offline
Joined: 19 Feb 2009
Posts: 1074
RE: Gaming Ps3 Vs Xbox 360

all the problems are rare on the ps3 really i think its 3% against 21% on the old xbox and 9% on the elite. but for £17 you get 3 years cover from game/gamestation so no worrys and you can then take further. and they swap it same day. for a trip out every year or so its worth it. ps3 sound is only better on some things online gameplay is not. unless my denon1909 is not good enough to show the ps3 off that could be. but for me they are almost the same. controller i think is what ever you get use to first. i like the xbox but they are both good. i just like 145k against 62k online same game same time ps3 has alot less online users and they offer it for free. as for xbox i set my nat as high and only get uk users and it works awesome, as i also hate the yanks jokes im sure they hate ares so its no attack on them.

__________________

Samsung 46 led tv-yamaha 673 -skyhd-wd tv live streaming;-wd my book 2tb nas-apple tv3-xbox360-aria gaming pc -genie2(2mred)-Montior Audio Br5's Br-LCR Br1's Brw10 sub-ipad(2g)-samsung gs2-akg 450

D.J.KRIME's picture
Offline
Joined: 28 Jun 2007
Posts: 2441
RE: Gaming Ps3 Vs Xbox 360

I have among both the 360 and PS3 and I play mainly online and for Me XBOX LIVE is head and shoulders infront of PSN, less lag for starters and IMHO the user interface on the 360 is also better the the PS3's. Only games I play on the PS3 are GT and Little Big Plannet.

__________________

My usefull posts Laughing How To Calibrate Your TV

TrevD's picture
Offline
Joined: 1 Aug 2009
Posts: 84
RE: Gaming

Xbox all the way!! I was a die hard playstation1/2 fan and wouldn't even consider the 1st xbox. But after all the initial delays with the ps3, my brother sold me on the 360 and I havnt looked back.

__________________

Pioneer PDP-LX508D

Arcam AVR600

Denon 3313

B&W XTC/4/2 +PV1 sub

Spectral Closed, Isotek G11Vision, All Chord Co. cables

SkyHD, XBox Elite, Harmony 1100

 

landzw's picture
Offline
Joined: 9 Jun 2009
Posts: 669
RE: Who's best Xbox or Playstation....

I did see a breakdown of data when the first xbox and ps3 arrived and well to us we would never notice the difference between the two machines in the terms of power. 

I personally think both machines are excellent

__________________

My Cheap Cheerful Setup

LG 50PA650T ,Talk Talk TV , Sony BDP-S4100 ,Now TV & Sound Organisation AV Rack 

Bose Soundlink, Shuffle With Bose SIE2 Sport Headphones