Have your say & ask the experts!

Uh-oh, Now He's Looking at DACs!

13 replies [Last post]
ESP2009
ESP2009's picture
Offline
Joined: 16 Feb 2009
Posts: 1787

A couple of years ago when I was first mucking about with my hi-fi system I purchased the re-vamped Cambridge DACMagic.  It seemed to work well with my set-up, although I admit that when I upgraded to the Primare CDP and amp, I took it out of the CD playback equation, although it still contributes to computer-based listening and also my limited AV set-up.

In anticipation of an influx of funds as a result of my sale of a lens on Fleabay, and following my butterfly-like deliberations over whether to buy a media streamer, a new camera, or even another lens, my thoughts came near to full circle when I began to wonder about a DAC upgrade.

The question is: will a sub-£1000 DAC such as the Rega or Audiolab M-DAC appreciably improve my listening via Primare CD31 and I30 combination and/or be a sensible upgrade to my listening from computer?

By the way, at the end of the various boxes and pieces of string is a pair of ProAc Studio 140 Mk2 speakers.

I suddenly realised that the Other Half is away for three nights, commencing Sunday, so I have very little time to seize an opportunity to audition something.  So, all contributions gratefully received on the advice front - PDQ!  Smile

__________________

Naim Uniti (24/192); ProAc Studio 140 Mk2 ; Synology DS212j & Logitech Squeezebox Touch (it's a kind of magic!) ; Fewer boxes and stringy bits than previously. Subject to change at a whim or WHF delivery.

CnoEvil
CnoEvil's picture
Offline
Joined: 21 Aug 2009
Posts: 8826
RE: Uh-oh, Now He's Looking at DACs!

IMO The real gains come when the CDP is taken out of the equation....so my advice is to sell the CDP (while people still want them) and replace with a competent Streamer + NAS (after a demo of course).

__________________

"Everything has been said before, but since nobody listens we have to keep going back and beginning all over again."  André Gide

ESP2009
ESP2009's picture
Offline
Joined: 16 Feb 2009
Posts: 1787
RE: Uh-oh, Now He's Looking at DACs!

Which brings me back to the original question I posed the other week about streamers, ho-hum!  doh!

__________________

Naim Uniti (24/192); ProAc Studio 140 Mk2 ; Synology DS212j & Logitech Squeezebox Touch (it's a kind of magic!) ; Fewer boxes and stringy bits than previously. Subject to change at a whim or WHF delivery.

CnoEvil
CnoEvil's picture
Offline
Joined: 21 Aug 2009
Posts: 8826
RE: Uh-oh, Now He's Looking at DACs!

ESP2009 wrote:

Which brings me back to the original question I posed the other week about streamers, ho-hum!  doh!

...zackly! banging head against wall

__________________

"Everything has been said before, but since nobody listens we have to keep going back and beginning all over again."  André Gide

shooter
shooter's picture
Offline
Joined: 4 May 2008
Posts: 2597
RE: Uh-oh, Now He's Looking at DACs!

I'm still not wholey convinced a PC is better than a dedicated transport, though its hard to do any real world demoing because the set is totally different. CD's for what they are will be around for many moons to come imo, yes i can see folk downloading and i have done myself but i still like a copy as back if not anything else, PC's have a shelf life shorter than a CD, thats good enough to buy them imo, this week alone i've bought 7 shocked The only thing that will take me away from buying CD's is Apple Cloud but only when it can stream CD quality, not interested in any lossy format for home listening. 

On a personnel note i'm putting a system together that should be finish very soon that i'll be able to compare PC audio to transport audio using a DAC/pre as the hub of the system with the transport will be connected to the dac via aes/ebu. I'm not 100% sure in the PC audio side of it and what would be a fair comparison, i could either stream via a Apple AEX (CD quality) it would then have to be Toslink Optical into the DAC or use something like a HiFace Evo from M2Tech or a Weiss INT202 then the aes/ebu into dac, i suppose i could try both  excellent!

ESP, hope ypur well, i never saw your streaming thread, stick a link up please.

What do you want your system to do its not doing now? Do you like the sound as is or would you like to take it in a different direction, sources are a great way of bring a new sound to the system.  Cool

 

 

Diamond Joe
Diamond Joe's picture
Offline
Joined: 1 Mar 2008
Posts: 1098
RE: Uh-oh, Now He's Looking at DACs!

I think this is ESP2009's streamer thread shooter. Please correct me if I'm wrong ESP old chap.  Smile

__________________

He's not a diamond geezer, or called Joe!

ESP2009
ESP2009's picture
Offline
Joined: 16 Feb 2009
Posts: 1787
RE: Uh-oh, Now He's Looking at DACs!

Diamond Joe wrote:

I think this is ESP2009's streamer thread shooter. Please correct me if I'm wrong ESP old chap.  Smile

Oi!  "Old chap"?!?!  OK, you're correct; that is the thread.

__________________

Naim Uniti (24/192); ProAc Studio 140 Mk2 ; Synology DS212j & Logitech Squeezebox Touch (it's a kind of magic!) ; Fewer boxes and stringy bits than previously. Subject to change at a whim or WHF delivery.

ESP2009
ESP2009's picture
Offline
Joined: 16 Feb 2009
Posts: 1787
RE: Uh-oh, Now He's Looking at DACs!

Shooter, thanks for the interesting post - I look forward to further updates.

For my own part, although I know I am getting a great sound, I always want to know what's over that next hill, as it were.  That aside, I am ready to accept that maybe streaming of high quality music is worthy of serious consideration.  It is not always convenient to access a CD of our choice, whereas if a computer-based system provides the same or better quality, I am more than willing to give it my attention.

__________________

Naim Uniti (24/192); ProAc Studio 140 Mk2 ; Synology DS212j & Logitech Squeezebox Touch (it's a kind of magic!) ; Fewer boxes and stringy bits than previously. Subject to change at a whim or WHF delivery.

shooter
shooter's picture
Offline
Joined: 4 May 2008
Posts: 2597
RE: Uh-oh, Now He's Looking at DACs!

 

No problem ESP, i can do a streamed aex/toslink optical to dac and a transport to dac set up. I should be picking up my dac at the end of the week and looking through the manual yesterday i can do a cat6 connection from transport to dac so have ordered a 1 meter Neutrik NKE6S-* Cool

This wont be an ideal set up as the cat6 and toslink connections are different beasts totally with the cat6 being far superior in bandwidth though but the aex is good as a streamer with a pretty low noise floor and low jitter output. I could buy a toslink to cat converter for the experimant but i'm not sure if anything i'll gain in in doing it. Its just another link/convertion that we could do without, i say keep it as simple as possible. Nothings ever easy and simple is it  banging head against wall

Diamond Joe
Diamond Joe's picture
Offline
Joined: 1 Mar 2008
Posts: 1098
RE: Uh-oh, Now He's Looking at DACs!

ESP2009 wrote:

Diamond Joe wrote:

I think this is ESP2009's streamer thread shooter. Please correct me if I'm wrong ESP old chap.  Smile

Oi!  "Old chap"?!?! 

Oh, well it wasn't intended to offend, or make a comment at your age (or worse) merely a (somewhat antiquated) form of address, better than mate IMO.  puzzled

__________________

He's not a diamond geezer, or called Joe!

ESP2009
ESP2009's picture
Offline
Joined: 16 Feb 2009
Posts: 1787
RE: Uh-oh, Now He's Looking at DACs!

Diamond Joe wrote:

ESP2009 wrote:

Diamond Joe wrote:

I think this is ESP2009's streamer thread shooter. Please correct me if I'm wrong ESP old chap.  Smile

Oi!  "Old chap"?!?! 

Oh, well it wasn't intended to offend, or make a comment at your age (or worse) merely a (somewhat antiquated) form of address, better than mate IMO.  puzzled

Smile None taken ole bean.  Evil  I'm with you on the 'mate' thing: far too familiar for my liking.  Wink

The OH is away again in a few weeks and I might see if I can get a DAC (or two) to try out. Although I am not sure if the Naim sound is for me, perhaps I might also try out a Uniti with the idea of ditching current CDP and amp.  Who knows?  Feeding into the ProAcs, it might fit right in.

__________________

Naim Uniti (24/192); ProAc Studio 140 Mk2 ; Synology DS212j & Logitech Squeezebox Touch (it's a kind of magic!) ; Fewer boxes and stringy bits than previously. Subject to change at a whim or WHF delivery.

ESP2009
ESP2009's picture
Offline
Joined: 16 Feb 2009
Posts: 1787
RE: Uh-oh, Now He's Looking at DACs!

shooter wrote:

 

No problem ESP, i can do a streamed aex/toslink optical to dac and a transport to dac set up. I should be picking up my dac at the end of the week and looking through the manual yesterday i can do a cat6 connection from transport to dac so have ordered a 1 meter Neutrik NKE6S-* Cool

This wont be an ideal set up as the cat6 and toslink connections are different beasts totally with the cat6 being far superior in bandwidth though but the aex is good as a streamer with a pretty low noise floor and low jitter output. I could buy a toslink to cat converter for the experimant but i'm not sure if anything i'll gain in in doing it. Its just another link/convertion that we could do without, i say keep it as simple as possible. Nothings ever easy and simple is it  banging head against wall

I look forward to your report.  I am not sure that simplicity really fits into hi-fi unless you're very lucky or, dare I say, readily satisfied with a combination of kit and resultant sound, without that drive to ask: "but what if?"

__________________

Naim Uniti (24/192); ProAc Studio 140 Mk2 ; Synology DS212j & Logitech Squeezebox Touch (it's a kind of magic!) ; Fewer boxes and stringy bits than previously. Subject to change at a whim or WHF delivery.

Diamond Joe
Diamond Joe's picture
Offline
Joined: 1 Mar 2008
Posts: 1098
RE: Uh-oh, Now He's Looking at DACs!

I've got to say that my thoughts keep gravitating back to the Naim Uniti, even more so since they announced the 2nd version. I like the idea of having everything I need in a tidy little package and I've always hankered after some Naim kit on my rack. I wonder if my local dealer could lend me one, I might e-mail him.  puzzled

Good luck with your search ESP.  Smile

__________________

He's not a diamond geezer, or called Joe!

ESP2009
ESP2009's picture
Offline
Joined: 16 Feb 2009
Posts: 1787
RE: Uh-oh, Now He's Looking at DACs!

Diamond Joe wrote:

I've got to say that my thoughts keep gravitating back to the Naim Uniti, even more so since they announced the 2nd version. I like the idea of having everything I need in a tidy little package and I've always hankered after some Naim kit on my rack. I wonder if my local dealer could lend me one, I might e-mail him.  puzzled

Good luck with your search ESP.  Smile

I must admit that having listened to a couple of Naim separates last year I have been a bit reluctant to give consideration to the range. I note that a post I saw elsewhere on the interweb did describe the Naim sound as sometimes "shouty".  I have to agree that this was an impression I got, too.  However, I am not averse to giving the Uniti a listen.  I might have to have a word with my local Music Matters branch...

__________________

Naim Uniti (24/192); ProAc Studio 140 Mk2 ; Synology DS212j & Logitech Squeezebox Touch (it's a kind of magic!) ; Fewer boxes and stringy bits than previously. Subject to change at a whim or WHF delivery.