Have your say & ask the experts!

SACD vs DVD Audio

26 replies [Last post]
GSB
GSB's picture
Offline
Joined: 27 Mar 2011
Posts: 1353
RE: SACD vs DVD Audio

As for sacd's,is there a good site anyone can recommend for purchasing?

Iv'e looked on amazon/fleabay(uk) but wondering if there's a dedicated place.

cheers

__________________

PanasonicTX-P46GT30B..Yamaha RX-A1010...Music Fidelity M3i...OPPO105EU...KEFR100/R200C/3001SE/HTB2SE...SkyHD2TB...QED Copper Speaker Cable /HDMI/Analogue...PS3...IPAD2

Ian986's picture
Offline
Joined: 26 Jan 2010
Posts: 163
RE: SACD vs DVD Audio

I have about 5 of each I can't say any format is better than the other only thing I can say is you can back up SACD to I tunes but only at standard cd quality 

I really enjoy listening to 5.1 music  blu rays all seem to be live and not as good quality 

__________________

Samsung 40 6600 LED TV Onkyo TXNR 809 MA Apex Oppo 103 

Al ears's picture
Offline
Joined: 23 Nov 2008
Posts: 2434
RE: SACD vs DVD Audio

fr0g wrote:

Fair enough, I deserved that.

But the lack of ability to back-up seriously put me off SACD. It's a shame that there is no multi-channel download option (as far as I am aware of).

 

 

I am not too sure why you would need to back-up an SACD if you hold the physical item in your hand.

(Or maybe I do Smile )

It's not as if it is a downloaded file that may corrupt.

__________________

Origin Live Aurora Gold+Illustrious Mk2 arm+Zyx R100-02/Stello CDT200+Stello DA220 dac/Tom Evans Groove Anniversary phono amp/Tom Evans Vibe preamp/Linear A power amp/Acoustic Zen Adagios/Chord cables/Oppo 105EU.

fr0g's picture
Offline
Joined: 7 Jan 2008
Posts: 2876
RE: SACD vs DVD Audio

Alears wrote:

fr0g wrote:

Fair enough, I deserved that.

But the lack of ability to back-up seriously put me off SACD. It's a shame that there is no multi-channel download option (as far as I am aware of).

 

 

I am not too sure why you would need to back-up an SACD if you hold the physical item in your hand.

(Or maybe I do Smile )

It's not as if it is a downloaded file that may corrupt.

 

I play everything from a NAS drive. I rarely use a CD player these days, and when I do it's more for nostalgia. I buy mainly downloads too from the likes of Boomkat (in FLAC format).

And I have everything backed up. So SACD is rather a pain. Yes the CD layer can be copied, but not any surround SACD layer, which kind of defeats the object.

__________________

“Out beyond ideas of wrong and  right, there is a field.

I'll meet you there."

 

 

shado's picture
Offline
Joined: 22 Aug 2008
Posts: 531
RE: SACD vs DVD Audio

Frog what it boils down to is an Active speaker set up vs Passive!

From my point of view my amp is capable of handling MP3 formats up to DVD audio without prejudice, you can tell noticeable differences between itunes/WAV/DTS/DVD(A) but all formats are still enjoyable plus I want to digress back into vinyl.  I am intrigued by what Active is shouting about in the digital arena which I am sure I will purchase idc but can they handle anologue formats as well?

__________________

AV - Samsung 40D8000, CA Azure751BD, Yamaha YSP2200

Hifi - Cyrus CD6SE, 8XPd, 6 Power, KEF iQ50, ZP90

Wifi - Cocktail Audio X10 1TB/NAS, Sonos S5/ZP90/120

Wharfedale Diamonds 9.0, B&W Zeppelin, Kef Picoforte
Soundscience Frankenspiel USB Speakers

Al ears's picture
Offline
Joined: 23 Nov 2008
Posts: 2434
RE: SACD vs DVD Audio

Help, help! We have been hijacked by the Active...sorry 'powered' speaker brigade!

What that has do do with the original post.

__________________

Origin Live Aurora Gold+Illustrious Mk2 arm+Zyx R100-02/Stello CDT200+Stello DA220 dac/Tom Evans Groove Anniversary phono amp/Tom Evans Vibe preamp/Linear A power amp/Acoustic Zen Adagios/Chord cables/Oppo 105EU.

Watsy1958's picture
Offline
Joined: 23 Dec 2013
Posts: 1
RE: SACD vs DVD Audio

If you have a hi end 5.1 system like myself then you hear the sound quality difference between sacd and dvd audio its so much of a difference sacd is just garbage, quality is just not there...Far as finding good dvd audio if you lazy and cheap of course you wont have a collection.

CnoEvil's picture
Online
Joined: 21 Aug 2009
Posts: 11414
RE: SACD vs DVD Audio

Watsy1958 wrote:

If you have a hi end 5.1 system like myself then you hear the sound quality difference between sacd and dvd audio its so much of a difference sacd is just garbage, quality is just not there...Far as finding good dvd audio if you lazy and cheap of course you wont have a collection.

Hi Watsy, and welcome to the forum.

BTW. What system do you have?

__________________

"Everything has been said before, but since nobody listens we have to keep going back and beginning all over again."  André Gide

pete321's picture
Offline
Joined: 20 Aug 2008
Posts: 1100
RE: SACD vs DVD Audio

Watsy1958 wrote:
sacd is just garbage, quality is just not there...

just shows how peoples tastes are different. I happen to think both are great compared to most CD's. My preference is with DSD (SACD), to my ears it gives a more natural and less clinical sound than hi-res PCM (DVD-A).

I now use J.River to convert all my PCM FLAC files to 5.6mhz DSD to playback via my DAC.

__________________

Sound: Naim Nait XS | PMC GB1i | Avondale Black Link speaker cable | PC with J River MC19 | Teac UD-501 DAC + Vetere D-Fi USB lead | Audio-Technica ATH-M50

Vision: Oppo BDP-105 | Pioneer PDP-LX5090 | Yamaha YSP-4100 | BK XLS300/PR Subwoofer

pete321's picture
Offline
Joined: 20 Aug 2008
Posts: 1100
RE: SACD vs DVD Audio

Ian986 wrote:
you can back up SACD to I tunes but only at standard cd quality

Unless you have a PS3 with old firmware, then you can rip the DSD layer, extract the individual tracks to dsf or dff files using sacd_extract & play them back via J.River to a DSD capable DAC, or convert to 24 bit PCM using Korg Audiogate.

__________________

Sound: Naim Nait XS | PMC GB1i | Avondale Black Link speaker cable | PC with J River MC19 | Teac UD-501 DAC + Vetere D-Fi USB lead | Audio-Technica ATH-M50

Vision: Oppo BDP-105 | Pioneer PDP-LX5090 | Yamaha YSP-4100 | BK XLS300/PR Subwoofer

pete321's picture
Offline
Joined: 20 Aug 2008
Posts: 1100
RE: SACD vs DVD Audio

As this is BD player thread, you can also use players like the Oppo 105 to convert a playing SACD to 88.2khz PCM, output the digital signal via SPDIF to a suitable PC audio card and record. You end up with a 24bit 88.2khz FLAC or WAV file.

__________________

Sound: Naim Nait XS | PMC GB1i | Avondale Black Link speaker cable | PC with J River MC19 | Teac UD-501 DAC + Vetere D-Fi USB lead | Audio-Technica ATH-M50

Vision: Oppo BDP-105 | Pioneer PDP-LX5090 | Yamaha YSP-4100 | BK XLS300/PR Subwoofer