Who wants their music on a phone? iDon't!

Andrew Everard 16 June 2008 17:29
As regular readers may know, I’m not the biggest fan of the Apple iPod.

Maybe it’s because I tend to do my commuting by car, but I’ve never really ‘got’ the appeal of having all my music in my pocket, ready for instant access.

Or maybe it’s because I’m old-fashioned enough to believe that music is something requiring you sit down and give your entire attention, not to form the backdrop to something else.

After all, you wouldn’t carry versions of great paintings around with you, just to have a swift glance now and then, would you? Music while you work?

No thanks – I find it to be a serious distraction.

That’s probably why all the news about the new iPhone – it’s now less expensive, and has ‘3G’ capability, among other features – leaves me rather cold. Yes, I carry a mobile phone around with me – it’s a company one, so I kind of have to – but the idea of using it to browse the internet while listening to music and making a call seems just too much.

And however exciting the touch-screen interface may be to the committed Apple fans, surely having to haul the thing out of your pocket just to change the volume level is more or less inviting a mugging in some of the more dangerous parts of the world?

Nevertheless, I'm sure we'll see queues outside Apple stores as the product goes on sale; after all, the day the new iPhone was announced the radio was awash with people talking about the product in terms roughly akin to the Second Coming.

But I’ll stick to phones that are phones, and music as it's meant to be enjoyed.

In calm, and quiet.

Filed under: , ,

Comments

timwileman June 17, 2008 11:39

i am with you 100% on this one.....i do have an ipod but only time is use it is when on hols attached to a speaker dock ..... so i can have my music while sipping a beer in antigua :-) nice

fr0g June 17, 2008 12:16

Each to their own. Would be an awfully boring world without difference of opinion. But I for one love to work, with my favorite tunes. Gardening, cooking and even working at my day job (when I have one) of computer programming.

I find it helps me relax, switches off the 'white noise' from the inevitable 'open office', and actually increases productivity.

They're also great on trains and planes and buses.

However. I agree on the phone thing... makes no sense to me to wear down the battery on a phone, given the diminunitive size of most standalone players.

iRog June 17, 2008 12:41

Well, I agree that music is distracting while working, and I agree that music should ideally be given attention and listened to in a calm and quiet environment. So as a frequent business traveller when I often find myself in a hotel room wanting to chill out and unwind, I appreciate having portable music. And since I also prefer to travel with as few devices and adaptors as possible, my Walkman phone has been great :)

jules153 June 17, 2008 15:19

Agreed AE.

IPods are good for holidays and that's about it. Playing your favorite music through the day on a low quality player just debases it. Wait until ya get home!

jules.

dirtydawg1967 June 18, 2008 22:23

Can't say I agree with you Jules153. I would say that iPods are far from a "low quality player" and are a very good player.  When paired up with a decent set of headphones the music is not debased at all. OK, so it's not the same experience as filling a room with finely tuned music but it's still a fantastic way to listen to music either through the 'phones or through a dock or in the car through the iPod interface. Oh and maybe for holidays as well.

Cheers

DD

Andrew Everard June 18, 2008 22:26

IME, "as a frequent business traveller" I find it much better to go out and find some local live music.

JoelSim June 19, 2008 21:57

I have a iPod, and a Walkman phone...

And I never listen to either of them. They are tinny and actually cause me to fall out of love with music. Give me a proper separates system any day. I hooked my IPod up to the amp one day and did an A/B test on the CD. To say there was absolutely no contest must be the understatement of the year.

Anonymous comments are disabled

About Andrew Everard

Andrew Everard, Audio Editor of Gramophone since November 1999 and What Hi-Fi? Sound and Vision's Consulting Editor, read English at Queens' College, Cambridge a very long time ago! He started his journalistic career in 1982 on Haymarket's photographic magazines, and subsequently worked on What Hi-Fi?, High Fidelity, Audiophile and Home Cinema magazines, as well as contributing a monthly column to Japanese title HiVi.