EXCLUSIVE REVIEW: Check out Toshiba's top-value 42XV505D Full HD LCD TV

Andy Clough
Fri, 23 May 2008, 10:13am

Tosh1

A 42in screen for £770 would have been unheard of a couple of years ago, but today's flatscreen TVs offer better value than ever.

Toshiba's latest LCD, the 42XV505D, is a case in point: for well under a grand you get a Full HD screen with Freeview tuner, 24fps support and multiple HDMI sockets. But has performance been compromised to keep that price competitive?

We've just tested it for the Ultimate Guide to Television, on sale June 5, but you can read our review exclusively online today.

Toshiba 42XV505D
5 stars
£770

For
Punchy, vibrant picture, with good sharpness and stability; value; good spec

Against

Black levels aren't quite as deep as those of some rival plasma sets; Freeview tuner can be a touch unsubtle

Verdict

Not necessarily perfect, but this elegant, well-specified Full HD set is a cracking value-for-money proposition


In recent years Toshiba has done very well with smaller screen LCD TVs, but struggled to compete at with rivals at bigger screens sizes. However, the acclaimed 40ZF355D (and its predecessor, the 40XF355D) changed the status quo rather nicely, and now it's the turn of the 42XV505D to keep up the good work.

It's quite clearly a good-value offering, this set. It's well-equipped, stylish and, with its Full HD resolution, 24fps support and multiple HDMIs, well-placed to deal with everything the Blu-ray future can throw at it.

Sound quality is similar to that of other Toshiba models we've tested, such as the 32C3030DB and 37C3030DB: that's to say, it avoids harshness or brightness, but lacks a little detail compared to the best in class.

Given some fine-tuning, the picture's very impressive: the image has lots of punch, terrific stability and an appealing verve.

There's no problem with motion, either from TV or from Blu-ray, and while the colour balance is ever-so-slightly warm, with a touch of exaggeration to red hues, the picture never strays into unnatural excess.

Tosh2

Freeview signals pose a sterner test: the Toshiba's 1920 x 1080 resolution means it has a lot of scaling work to do, and while it manages to keep noise well in check, the picture is still less subtle and stable than with DVD or HD content.

Black level insight is the traditional LCD weak spot relative to large-screen plasma alternatives, and here the Toshiba is undoubtedly outpointed by Panasonic's same-size, same-resolution TH-42PZ80.

But in other regards, notably edge definition, the Toshiba has the edge, and it's also cheaper. That, coupled to everything else that it offers for your money, means this is one set you should definitely see for yourself.

TECH SPECS

Type LCD

Aspect Ratio 16:9

HD Ready Yes

Full HD Yes

Screen size (in) 42

Resolution 1920 x 1080

Accepts 1080p Yes

24fps Yes

HDMI 1.3a Yes

Integrated analogue tuner Yes

Integrated digital tuner Yes

HDMI in 3

DVI in 0

PC in 1

Component in 1

RGB Scart in 2

Scart in 0

S-Video in 1

Composite in 1

USB in 0

Memory card in 0

Phono audio in 2

Phono audio out 1

Digital audio out 1

Dimensions (hwd, cm) 67 x 101 x 31

Weight (kg) 23

Technorati Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Comments

Oh No I was going for  Pana 42PX80, but this tosh is looking really tempting..What to do.... Full HD LCD or HD Ready Plasma?....Damn!!!

I'd get the plasma every time. The black levels on these Toshiba LCDs are just terrible - I've had one and I got rid of it after a year. It's not just that black isn't black, it's that very dark grey is black and black is sometimes very dark blue, no matter what user or engineer settings you tweak.

Cheers Fisty Thats helped my waivering resolve.

Toshiba 37XV505DB......just muddied my waters [had settled on Panasonic LZD800] and now see the 37" version of  this  Tosh for £620!!!

HOWEVER......one site describes unit as " Full HD" one as "HD READY" and one as " Full HD READY"...what is the difference and what on earth do I do???

Advice please

Huw

Fisty, I don't see how you can compare a Toshiba LCD that is over a year old with the latest models which you have probably not even seen.

Snoffy...look instead at the Panasonic 42PZ80 - full HD at around £840 online (delivered).

dree, I understand what you're saying but I'm talking from not only the experience of owning a Tosh LCD over a year ago, it's from looking at the new models (though not this particular one) in the shops and seeing the /exact same black level problems/ as my unit had. It's also from reading comments about the black levels ("not quite as good as some rivals"-type thing) in every review of Tosh LCD hardware I've ever read.

Put a recent Tosh next to a recent Panasonic for example and the PQ difference is as plain as the nose on your face.